Artificial Intelligence-Based Crop Recommendation Using Soil and Climate Data: A Comprehensive Review of Machine Learning, Deep Learning, and Smart Agriculture Approaches

Abstract

Crop recommendation systems that integrate soil and climate data with artificial intelligence (AI) have expanded rapidly since 2020, spanning classical machine learning (ML), ensemble methods, deep learning, explainable AI (XAI), and Internet of Things (IoT)-enabled sensing. This review critically synthesizes 35 sources — 33 peer-reviewed journal articles and conference papers plus 2 preprints retained only for background context — comprising 12 studies verified in full against their primary text and 23 studies verified at the bibliographic level, to examine what has been attempted, which data and algorithms have been used, and how reliable the reported results are. The reviewed literature shows convergent use of a narrow feature set (nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium, temperature, humidity, pH, and rainfall) and recurring near-ceiling accuracy, including cases at or above 98% [1], [5], [6] and, in one case, a reported 1.00 across accuracy, precision, recall, and F1-score following class-balancing [7]. Cross-examination of dataset descriptions across studies reveals inconsistent provenance and documentation: structurally similar seven-feature datasets are described with different national contexts and reported sample sizes ranging from 2,100 to 3,000 records [5], [6], [9]. Validation practice is dominated by random hold-out or k-fold cross-validation; among the studies examined in full, only one tested spatial cross-validation, reporting a substantial performance decline (AUC 0.89 to 0.55–0.62) relative to random-split results [4]. Explainable AI and uncertainty quantification remain minority practices in the reviewed literature. A prior conference proceedings paper self-described as a