The Optimal Discounting Parameter of the Power Prior under Predictive Log-Loss

Abstract

The power prior of Ibrahim and Chen incorporates historical data into a Bayesian analysis by raising the historical likelihood to a power $a_0 \in [0, 1]$. The choice of the exponent has remained an open question. This paper gives a closed-form answer under the predictive log-loss. For a model with $d$ parameters, a historical sample of size $N_0$, and average Kullback--Leibler divergence $\bar{D}_0$ between the historical and current data-generating distributions, the optimal exponent is $a_0^{*} = d/(2 N_0 \bar{D}_0 + d)$. Equivalently, the optimally borrowed effective sample size obeys the harmonic law $1/E^{*} = 1/N_0 + 2\bar{D}_0/d$: compatible data are pooled in full, and any difference caps the borrowed information at $d/(2\bar{D}_0)$ observations. The result is exact for multinomial data and extends to smooth parametric families. The law benchmarks adaptive borrowing, explains the reported degeneracy of the normalized power prior, and shows that neither subsetting the data nor decaying the exponent improves on the correctly discounted constant.