Skip to content
Preprint

Benchmarking Universal Machine Learning Force Fields for Molecular Dynamics of Lunar Regolith Minerals

Jul 2026 · 0 citations · 29 references
Physics

Abstract

Universal machine-learning interatomic potentials provide a promising route for accelerating molecular dynamics simulations of materials, but their transferability to lunar regolith-relevant silicates, oxides, and hydrogen-bearing surface species remains elucidated. Here, we benchmark six foundation models, MACE-MH, MatterSim, SevenNet-0, UPET, UMA, and NequIP-OAM-L, using NVT molecular dynamics simulations of four representative lunar minerals: forsterite, fayalite, ilmenite, and anorthite. Structural fidelity is evaluated using temperature stability, bond-distance statistics, bond-angle distributions, and partial radial distribution functions, with comparison to crystallographic reference data. The models reproduce Si--O, Mg--O, Al--O, and Ca--O local environments reasonably well, while Fe--O and Ti--O coordination environments show broader distributions and larger short-timescale fluctuations, highlighting the need for further validation and fine tuning with additional ground truth data for Fe- and Ti-bearing lunar phases. Hydroxylated surface tests show consistent O--H bond-distance distributions across models and minerals, suggesting that these foundation models may provide useful starting points for screening surface hydroxyl stability and volatile-related processes. Performance benchmarks on a single NVIDIA RTX 4090 show that SevenNet-0, MatterSim, and UPET provide the highest throughput among the six tested models, MACE-MH remains practical at intermediate cost, and UMA and NequIP-OAM-L extend the comparison to newer foundation potentials at higher runtime cost and memory demand. These results provide an initial benchmark for applying universal foundation models to lunar mineral simulations and identify key directions for future ab initio validation, model fine-tuning, and applications to lunar volatile evolution, space weathering, ISRU, and polar sample return studies.

View source

Similar papers

Preprint Aug 2026

Data-Efficient Construction of Material-Specific Machine-Learning Interatomic Potentials from Ab Initio Molecular Dynamics Trajectories

Pretrained machine-learning interatomic potentials, so-called universal or foundation models offer an appealing starting point for atomistic simulations, but their accuracy for material-specific observables often remains limited without additional reference data (fine-tuning). Here, we systematically quantify how much first-principles data are required to convert universal models into ab initio-accurate material-specific potentials, and ask whether fine-tuning is necessarily preferable to training from scratch. We compare five universal MLIP frameworks, MACE-MP-0, SevenNet-0, GRACE-1L-OAM, MatterSim-v1-5M and ORB-v2, across seven chemically diverse systems incorporating rare and reactive events. Fine-tuning on only 10 AIMD-derived configurations is insufficient for the investigated systems; 200 configurations succeed in favorable cases, but the outcome remains strongly system-dependent. By contrast, 2000 AIMD configurations constitute a robust default, yielding low force and energy errors and reproducing the target material-specific observables. Moderately dense sub-sampling of the AIMD trajectory reduces the required trajectory length tenfold with little loss in model quality. Training from scratch on the same datasets is competitive with, and often slightly more accurate than, naive fine-tuning for MACE and SevenNet, whereas GRACE requires more data. The energy profile for a sulfur-vacancy jump in MoS$_2$ reveals that low trajectory-level errors do not guarantee a correct reaction profile, highlighting the need for observable-level validation. Finally, we show that averaging independently trained models improves predictions in scarce-data regimes at no additional first-principles cost. Together, these results provide practical guidelines for converting limited AIMD reference data into reliable material-specific MLIPs for nanosecond-timescale simulations at near-DFT accuracy.

Jonas Hänseroth, Christian Dreßler · 0 citations
Preprint Sep 2026

Benchmarking Universal Machine Learning Force Fields for Crystal Structure Prediction of High-Energy Molecular Systems

Recent developments of universal machine learning interatomic potentials (UMLIPs) offer a fast route for screening molecular crystals based on geometry relaxation and energy ranking, but their reliability across chemically diverse energetic materials remains elusive. In particular, it is unclear whether or not these UMLIPs are over-sensitive to break the desired molecular connectivity for relaxing the periodic crystals. Herein we tested the hypothesis that classical force-field pre-relaxation can provide a more suitable starting geometry for subsequent UMLIP relaxation on a large database of high energy molecular crystals. Three models (MACE, MACE-OFF and UMA) in conjunction with the General Amber Force Field (GAFF) were applied to test this hypothesis. Among them, direct MACE-OFF and UMA showed very high relaxation success and preserved the reference geometries most closely, but they still exhibit failures for some rare cases. Using GAFF pre-relaxation can systematically reduce the number of failed relaxations with lower computational costs. Our comparative failure and robustness analyses revealed distinct trade-offs among the evaluated models. Among them, MACE-OFF achieves a better compromise between potential energy surface smoothness, structural fidelity, and stress convergence, serving as a good choice to provide a reliable foundation for automated structural optimization.

Unknown authors · 0 citations
Preprint Aug 2026

Cross-Geometry Transferability Assessment of Universal Machine Learning Interatomic Potentials: From Bulk Materials to Atomic Nanowires

Foundation machine-learning interatomic potentials (MLIPs) enable atomistic simulations at substantially lower computational cost than first-principles methods, but their reliability across structural geometries remains insufficiently understood. Here, we construct a density-functional-theory dataset of ZrO2 configurations spanning bulk, slab, particle, neck, and atomically thin wire environments motivated by an experimentally observed ZrO2 desintering process involving neck thinning and atomic wire formation. We first benchmark 26 pretrained MLIPs and observe pronounced geometry-dependent degradation in zero-shot predictions. Without any training, after only reference-energy alignment, the best zero-shot model (ORB-V3) reaches energy and force root-mean-square errors of 6 meV/atom and 197.3 meV/{\AA}, respectively, with the largest force errors in neck and wire configurations. We then compare zero-shot inference, fine-tuning, and training from scratch strategies. Fine-tuning yields lower energy and force errors than training from scratch, while both require comparable wall-clock time. Geometry-specific fine-tuning improves in-domain accuracy but frequently produces negative transfer to other structural classes, whereas mixed-geometry fine-tuning reduces cross-geometry errors. Evaluations of elastic and vibrational properties, surface energies, and neck dynamics further show that rankings based on average energy and force errors do not universally predict property-level behavior. These results demonstrate that geometry-diverse target data and independent physical validations are necessary when adapting foundation MLIPs to low-coordination (ionic) nanostructures.

P. Zanineli, B. Focassio, G. R. Schleder · 0 citations
Open access Jul 2026

Foundational Machine‐Learning Interatomic Potential for Simulating Chemically Complex Ni‐Based Superalloys

For decades, atomistic simulation of chemically complex Ni‐based superalloys has remained beyond practical reach. Here, we apply the GRACE foundational machine‐learning interatomic potential to predict chemical ordering and stacking‐fault energetics in the γ$\gamma$ and γ′$\gamma &aposx;$ phases of CMSX‐4, a commercial multicomponent Ni‐based superalloy. After benchmarking against structural and thermodynamic reference data, we use hybrid Monte‐Carlo/molecular dynamics sampling to study the impact of local chemical order on planar‐fault energies. GRACE reproduces elemental equilibrium lattice parameters within 0.50%$0.50\%$ of DFT references, while underestimating melting temperatures of ordered Ni–Al phases by up to 5.7%$5.7\%$ . The simulations reveal local chemical ordering in the γ$\gamma$ phase and the expected L12$\mathrm{L1_{2}}$ sublattice occupancies in the γ′$\gamma &aposx;$ phase. In the γ$\gamma$ phase, the short‐range order raises the shear barriers by approximately 66 mJ m−2$66~\mathrm{mJ\,m^{-2}}$ while leaving the intrinsic stacking fault energy of 28 mJ m−2$28~\mathrm{mJ\,m^{-2}}$ unchanged. In the γ′$\gamma &aposx;$ phase, alloying raises the complex and superlattice intrinsic stacking fault energies by approximately 100 mJ m−2$100~\mathrm{mJ\,m^{-2}}$ relative to stoichiometric Ni3$\mathrm{Ni_{3}}$ Al. These results show that pretrained foundational potentials enable atomistic simulations of chemically complex multicomponent superalloys at scales inaccessible to direct first‐principles calculations.

Aditya Vishwakarma, Sarath Menon, Fritz Körmann et al. · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Machine Learning-Driven Refinement of Reactive Force Fields via Hierarchical “Center-Environment” Features for Energetic Molecular Crystals

This work not only establishes a pioneering paradigm for interpretable ML-driven force field refinement but also provides the first feature engineering solution incorporating chemical, physical, and structural information specifically designed for the machine learning of energetic molecular crystals.

Qi He, Pengju Wang, Xudong He et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.