Skip to content
Preprint

What a Shorter Contest Really Costs: Serial Dependence, Effective Trials, and Evidence from a Rule Change in Professional Esports

Oct 2026 · 0 citations · 51 references
Economics

Abstract

Operational research evaluates tournament formats by their efficacy, the probability that the design identifies the stronger competitor, and computes it almost exclusively by simulation under an assumption that is rarely tested: that the trials a format aggregates are independent. We show that this assumption systematically overstates what shortening a contest costs, and we measure the correction. When trials are serially correlated, a format carries N/[1+(N-1)rho] effective trials rather than N, so a twenty per cent cut costs 10.6 per cent of discriminating power under independence but only 5.2 per cent at the correlation we estimate, and only 2.1 per cent in a sixty-trial format. The ingredients are estimated from an implemented change in contest length: in September 2023 professional Counter-Strike cut regulation rounds per map from thirty to twenty-four. Across 72,576 maps we measure discrimination as the ability slope over the residual standard deviation on the first half of a map, a contest fixed by rule at fifteen or twelve rounds with no stopping rule. Against the calibrated benchmark of 0.948, discrimination falls by thirty-five per cent in a ten-month window around the switch (0.648, 95 per cent interval 0.52-0.81) and by ten per cent over the full panel (0.901, 0.82-0.99). The correction needs one number, recoverable from ordinary results data as a design effect.

View source

Similar papers

Preprint Oct 2026

Rewarding Noise: Incentives in Decentralized A/B Testing

Many firms that run A/B tests struggle with low statistical power, increasing the risk that launch decisions are driven by noise rather than true impact. We argue that in decentralized organizations, low power can reflect misaligned incentives: product teams choose what and how to test on a customer-facing experience t...

Ryan E. Kessler · 0 citations
Preprint Nov 2026

Prizes, Shared Hazard, and the Speed of Frontier AI

Frontier AI labs compete in a contest for commercial leadership while sharing the risk of catastrophe. Each lab gains from arriving earlier but bears only part of the hazard its speed adds, which this paper calls the hazard externality. In an illustrative calibrated takeoff model, three racing labs get through the take...

L. Gan · 0 citations
Review Open access Oct 2026

Overview

The second issue of *Foundations* carries eight entries in two movements. The first movement takes up the statistical concepts that the inaugural issue used without naming, beginning from the loose end it left: a hedonic regression that missed one of eight Pacifica comparables by $46,455. Four entries form a chain, eac...

W. Craytor · 0 citations
Preprint Nov 2026

Comparing the Empirical Content of Economic Theories

A fitted theory that predicts well may do so because of the structure it commits to or because it was fitted to the data it is evaluated on. We propose measures that separate the two by operationalising a theory as a functional form, a support restriction on behavior and a distribution over the parameters, with no para...

Johanna Einsiedler · 0 citations
Open access Nov 2026

Deciding in the shadow of the state: when regulatory logic collides with market logic

Capital allocation models treat planning inputs as market-governed, even when they originate from political authority. Written for The Practice of Making Decisions section of Management Decision, this paper develops a three-phase response: classify each input, stress test it against a change of authority and design...

Amadeus Gabriel · 0 citations
Preprint Nov 2026

Unequal Rewards and the Direction of Scientific Work: Evidence from U.S. Public Universities

Research on pay dispersion has long asked whether unequal rewards increase or depress performance. Tournament theory expects stronger effort, while social comparison accounts expect withdrawal. Both perspectives, however, treat performance as a single scale on which workers can be ranked. Scientific work often resists...

Li-Kun Cao · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.