Skip to content
Open access

ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE: THE PROBLEM OF LEGAL PERSONALITY IN CIVIL LAW RELATIONS

Sep 2026 · TSUL Legal Report · Vol 7, pp. 60-66 · 0 citations

Abstract

The article addresses the problem of determining the civil law status of artificial intelligence systems. The study analyses the four principal approaches developed in international legal doctrine on this issue: recognition of artificial intelligence as an object of civil law, the electronic agent model, the concept of limited legal personality (quasi-subject), and the idea of electronic personhood. The article reveals the normative origins of the electronic agent construction, its attributive function in contractual relations, and its limitations in the field of tort law; the quasi-subject model is assessed on the basis of the theory of divisible legal capacity and the criteria of legitimacy. It is further demonstrated that the concept of electronic personhood cannot be justified under the interest criterion, since it does not give rise to any new interest requiring protection but, on the contrary, creates the risk of establishing a liability shield. As a result of the study, the article examines the applicability of the institutions of representation, transactions, and torts under the Civil Code of the Republic of Uzbekistan to relations involving autonomous systems, and puts forward proposals for introducing a special regime for artificial intelligence while retaining its status as an object of law.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access Nov 2026

CIVIL LAW STATUS OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE SYSTEMS: LEGAL PERSONALITY OR LEGAL REGIME OF A COMPLEX OBJECT?

The rapid advancement of artificial intelligence (AI) technologies poses fundamental challenges to traditional civil law frameworks worldwide. This article examines the dichotomy between two principal approaches to determining the civil law status of AI systems: recognizing AI as a subject of law with electronic person...

G. Mukaldyeva, Z. Zhagypar · 0 citations
Sep 2026

The Civil Law aspect of Artificial Intelligence: A Personality or Cognitive Technology?

The purpose of this study is to establish the legal essence of artificial intelligence, which is considered by modern legal theorists both as a potential subject of civil law relations and as a tool through which an artificial intelligence operator implements his own legal personality without creating a new face of civ...

Petr S. Fedoseev · 0 citations
Open access 2026

Theoretical Problems of AI Integration into the State-Legal Field

The article presents generalizations made by the author based on a doctrinal analysis of the practice of introducing artificial intelligence into the public legal sphere. The purpose of the article is to show the deep contradictions that arise at the junction of the ontology of human freedom, which is the basis of law,...

N. Chernogor · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Legal Liability of Artificial Intelligence in the Civil Service of Turkmenistan

There is a need to develop a comprehensive national strategy for AI regulation in Turkmenistan, and it proposes using the city of Arkadag as an experimental legal platform for testing innovative regulatory approaches.

М. Р. Сарыев, Myahri Yalkapova · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Legal Liability in the Use of AI and AI Agents: Theory and International Practice.

This article examines the scientific theory and international practice regarding legal liability associated with the use of artificial intelligence (AI) and AI agents. Particular attention is paid to liability criteria, the nature of violations, and regulatory issues within relevant branches of law. The analysis is con...

N. Nugmanov, Venera Sayfullaeva · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Artificial intelligence and judicial discretion: a comparative legal analysis of the limits of permissible use

The article examines the problem of the influence of artificial intelligence on judicial discretion. It is substantiated that the issue of using artificial intelligence in judicial activity cannot be reduced merely to the technical modernization of justice. A more significant issue is the limits of permissible influenc...

Y. Onosov · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.