On Property Rights and Taxation in the Case Law of the European Court of Human Rights
Abstract
Problem setting. In the modern world, which is developing amid rapid changes across all spheres of social life driven by globalization, digitalization, and the proliferation of digital currencies, approaches to such traditional and established institutions as property, property rights, and taxation are also undergoing transformation. Accordingly, certain aspects of the mechanisms through which the state distributes social wealth are evolving as well, seeking to remain socially acceptable while simultaneously enabling public territorial entities to fulfil their fundamental tasks and functions. Instead of the strict and customary centralization of resource management and public finances, emphasis is increasingly placed on the financial autonomy of territorial communities. Likewise, tax payments are no longer viewed solely as fiscal instruments but are increasingly expected to perform functions of economic stimulation, enhancement of business activity, and attraction of domestic and foreign investment. Through the prism of the fundamental principle of equality in taxation, these developments are reflected in the concept of a fair tax burden and the creation of equal competitive conditions. At the same time, there is a growing need for new approaches to balancing public and private interests within tax law regimes, while the scope of permissible property rights enjoyed by individuals bearing a socially significant tax burden is also changing and expanding. This naturally affects the concepts of property rights protection and the legal regimes governing the property of both private individuals and corporate entities, as developed by such an influential and authoritative judicial institution within the European legal space as the European Court of Human Rights (hereinafter – the ECtHR), which serves as a guarantor of States’ compliance with the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms [1]. Today, the ECtHR has become a leading architect of modern property rights protection in Europe. Through its case law, the Court has significantly expanded traditional national understandings of property, establishing substantial and effective legal guarantees for both natural and legal persons. These guarantees are designed to protect the rights and legitimate private interests of such persons against arbitrariness on the part of the State and against the unjustified expansion of discretionary powers exercised by public authorities when determining various obligations. The study of the ECtHR’s case law makes it possible to develop a comprehensive understanding of the most current European doctrine in the field of property rights protection and of the legal mechanisms used to balance public and private interests in taxation. Analysis of Recent Research and Publications. Certain aspects of the application of the case law of the European Court of Human Rights in the field of taxation have already attracted scholarly attention. I. Babin and O. Dmytryk examined the place of ECtHR judgments within the system of sources of financial and tax law, as well as the specific features of their application by Ukrainian courts in tax disputes [2; 3]. A. Beresten and P. Selezen focused on the significance of the ECtHR’s case law for the protection of taxpayers’ rights [4; 5]. N. Blazhivska and other scholars analysed the approaches adopted by the ECtHR in resolving tax disputes and in shaping standards for the protection of taxpayers’ rights [6]. In addition, researchers have examined issues of disproportionate taxation and excessive individual burden in the context of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention; the State’s right to taxation through the prism of the Convention and the limits of fiscal discretion; the relationship between anti-tax-avoidance measures and the protection of taxpayers’ property rights; as well as issues concerning the fiscal autonomy of states and the principle of subsidiarity within the legal framework of the Council of Europe [7–9], among others. Purpose of the Article. The purpose of this article is to provide a comprehensive analysis of the case law of the European Court of Human Rights concerning the protection of property rights in the field of taxation and to outline the significance of the standards developed by the ECtHR for tax law enforcement in Ukraine. Article’s Main Body. The article provides a comprehensive analysis of the case law of the European Court of Human Rights concerning the protection of property rights in the field of taxation. It examines the ECtHR’s approaches to the interpretation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms as an international legal guarantee of the property rights of natural and legal persons against disproportionate state interference. It is established that the Court’s contemporary jurisprudence is based on the doctrine of the “living instrument” and the concept of “European consensus,” which ensure the evolutionary interpretation of the Convention’s provisions in accordance with modern social and economic challenges. Particular attention is paid to the “three rules doctrine,” which is used by the ECtHR to assess the lawfulness and proportionality of state interference with an individual’s property rights. It is emphasized that the concept of “possessions” in the ECtHR’s case law has an autonomous and broad meaning and encompasses not only tangible objects but also a wide range of economic interests, assets, and legitimate expectations, including the right to tax refunds from the state budget, social benefits, licences, corporate rights, and other proprietary interests. A number of the Court’s judgments are analysed, focusing on taxpayers’ legitimate expectations as well as the admissibility of the retroactive application of tax legislation. Conclusions. It is determined that, when resolving tax disputes, the ECtHR proceeds from the necessity of ensuring a fair balance between the public interests of the state and individual property rights, taking into account the principles of legal certainty, good governance, and proportionality. It is concluded that the standards developed by the Court are of significant importance for improving tax law enforcement in Ukraine and ensuring the effective protection of taxpayers’ rights.