Current trends in the development of legal positions of the European Court of Human Rights regarding public finances
Abstract
The article examines current trends in the development of the legal positions of the European Court of Human Rights in the field of public finance. It is substantiated that the ECtHR’s case law in this area is dynamic and evolutionary in nature, which is determined by the concept of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms as a “living instrument” and by the need to interpret it in light of contemporary social, economic, and geopolitical conditions. It is established that, while ensuring consistency and predictability in its case law, the Court is not absolutely bound by its previous judgments and, where sufficient grounds exist, may revise previously formulated legal positions in an evolutionary manner. It is determined that the main body of ECtHR case law in the field of public finance has developed primarily within tax relations and is mainly related to the protection of property rights guaranteed by Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention. The development of the Court’s legal positions concerning the right to a fair trial, the right to an effective remedy, the prohibition of double punishment for the same offence, the prevention of discrimination in taxation, and the protection of private life in connection with public authorities’ access to financial and banking information is analysed. Drawing on recent ECtHR case law, the article demonstrates increasingly stringent requirements regarding the quality of national legislation, the justification of State interference with property rights, the availability of effective judicial review, and sufficient procedural safeguards against the arbitrary exercise of public discretion. It is concluded that the contemporary development of ECtHR case law in the field of public finance is characterised by the combination of two interrelated trends: recognition of a wide margin of appreciation afforded to States in matters of budgetary and tax policy, and, at the same time, strengthened scrutiny of compliance with the principles of legality, proportionality, the rule of law, and effective protection of individuals. Against the background of the growing importance of financial security, sanctions, and other extraordinary public-law measures, the Court continues to require States to maintain a fair balance between the general interests of society and the rights and legitimate interests of private persons.