Skip to content
Open access

The Effectiveness of Physical and Technology-based Virtual Manipulatives in Enhancing Student Engagement: A Meta-analysis

2026 · International Journal of Information and Education Technology · Vol 16, pp. 2223-2232 · 0 citations · 40 references

TL;DR

The study recommends that educators and curriculum developers strategically incorporate both physical and technology-based virtual manipulatives into instructional design and encourages further research to explore moderating variables such as educational level, manipulative type, mathematics content, and intervention duration.

Abstract

This meta-analysis investigates the effectiveness of physical and technology-based virtual manipulative instructional materials in enhancing students’ engagement across elementary, secondary, and tertiary education. Drawing on 10 empirical studies published from 2020 to 2024 that yielded 15 individual effect sizes, this study synthesized the quantitative data using Hedges’ g under a random-effects model. The overall pooled effect size was large and statistically significant, indicating substantial improvement in student engagement after using manipulatives. The included studies addressed a variety of mathematics topics, such as trigonometry, algebra, set theory, calculus, geometry, logic reasoning, and multiplication fluency. They also used diverse manipulatives: physical, technology-based, virtual, and combined approaches. Despite considerable heterogeneity, the robustness of the findings was supported by a Fail-safe N of 1564 and significant results from the equivalence test. Potential publication bias was suggested through Egger’s regression and Kendall’s tau tests, but the observed effect remained highly reliable. The results affirm the pedagogical value of manipulatives in promoting behavioral, cognitive, and emotional aspects in mathematics learning. The study recommends that educators and curriculum developers strategically incorporate both physical and technology-based virtual manipulatives into instructional design and encourages further research to explore moderating variables such as educational level, manipulative type, mathematics content, and intervention duration.

Read PDF

Similar papers

#data science Open access Jan 2027

Effects of a Simulation-Based Intervention on Learning and Metacognition

The findings show that PhET virtual simulations, when purposefully integrated into structured inquiry-based pedagogy and supported by explicit scaffolding, can serve as an effective educational tool for strengthening conceptual understanding and academic performance in tertiary physics instruction.

Noe T. Hermosa, Nenia Rose S. Hermosa, Grenny I. Junco · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Technology-Supported Interventions and Learners’ Metacognition: A Three-Level Meta-Analysis

Despite the growing use of educational technologies, including AI and generative AI, how these technologies support learners’ metacognition remains insufficiently understood. The present study synthesised 33 studies using a three-level meta-analysis. Technology-supported interventions were associated with higher metaco...

Yi-Jia Yuan, Yi-Ran Du · 1 citation
#software testing Review Open access Jan 2027

Digital Technology Integration and Academic Performance in Tertiary Mathematics: A Meta-Analytic Review of Pedagogy and Learning Results

The findings indicate a large overall effect size, suggesting that digital technologies significantly enhance academic achievement compared to traditional instructional methods, and that the impact of digital tools is contingent upon specific moderator variables.

L. Navarro-Ibarra, Omar Cuevas-Salazar, Alan D. Robles-Aguilar · 0 citations
Open access 2026

Teachers’ use of manipulatives in Mathematics 2 instruction: Utilization, perceived effectiveness, and instructional challenges

The use of manipulatives provides elementary learners with opportunities to explore mathematical concepts through concrete and meaningful experiences. This study examined the utilization of manipulatives in teaching Mathematics 2 and teachers’ perceptions of their effectiveness, challenges, instructional areas requirin...

Laida Angelica Jacinto · 0 citations
Review Open access 2026

The Effectiveness of the Teaching Games for Understanding Model in Badminton Service Learning: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Objective: The badminton serve is a fundamental technical skill that influences rally initiation and overall performance. Traditional instruction often isolates technique from tactical decision-making, limiting meaningful skill transfer. The Teaching Games for Understanding (TGfU) model offers a constructivist, game-ce...

Khairul Hamsyah, S. Nopembri, H. Hermawan et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.