Skip to content
Open access

Discrepancy between collapsed cone and Monte Carlo algorithms in lung inhomogeneity correction

Sep 2026 · Biomedical engineering and physics express · Vol 12 · 0 citations · 29 references
Physics Medicine

TL;DR

Evaluated the accuracy of collapsed cone (CC) algorithm for dose calculation in the presence of lung inhomogeneity compared to the Monte Carlo (MC) algorithm as the reference and recommended increasing the minimum segment width to >0.5 cm in IMRT plans if CC algorithm is used.

Abstract

Stereotactic body radiation therapy (SBRT) is a well-established standard of treatment for non-small cell lung cancer patients. However, SBRT is a double-edged sword and a high degree of accuracy is required for dose calculations. In the presence of inhomogeneity, it should be below 3% and depends strongly on the accuracy of the algorithm used for dose calculation in treatment planning system (TPS). The aim of this study is to evaluate the accuracy of collapsed cone (CC) algorithm for dose calculation in the presence of lung inhomogeneity compared to the Monte Carlo (MC) algorithm as the reference. The study conducted on a wide range of photon fields from 0.5 × 0.5 cm2 to 10 × 10 cm2. Monaco® TPS equipped with CC and MC algorithms in 6 MV, 10 MV, and 18 MV photons was employed and the inhomogeneity correction factor and PPDs were calculated inside an in-house inhomogeneous phantom. Finally, the results were compared between two algorithms. For 6 MV photons, gamma index pass rate (GIPR) with (2 mm, 3%) criteria in a 0.5 × 0.5 cm2 field is only 71.3%. The CC algorithm will not be able to confidently reproduce the PDDs in this field. For 1 × 1 cm2, 2 × 2 cm2, and 3 × 3 cm2 fields, the accuracy of the CC algorithm can increase to above 98%. For SBRT of small lung lesions, the results recommend increasing the minimum segment width to >0.5 cm in IMRT plans if CC algorithm is used. Independent of field size, the accuracy of CC algorithm decreases with increasing energy. For 10 and 18 MV photons, average GIPR under (2 mm, 3%) criteria was 97.9% and 92.0%, respectively, which are not of clinical interest.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Iranian Journal of Medical Physics

The evaluated five DCAs include Monte Carlo algorithm employed by Monaco, pencil beam convolution and anisotropic analytical algorithms employed by Eclipse and Superposition, and Clarkson algorithms employed by PCRT3D TPSs had different levels of accuracy in TPSs.

N. Kavousi, H. Nedaie, S. Gholami et al. · 0 citations

Evaluation of the dosimetric leaf gap for VMAT-SBRT in small target volumes

This study aims to tune the measured DLG for the lung and prostate using the VMAT-SBRT technique by using electronic portal imaging (EPID), and recommends tuning from the gamma passing rate per arc to avoid dose washing out.

Grit Phianpholdeesakun · 0 citations
Sep 2026

Monte Carlo intercomparison of TG-43 dosimetric parameters for clinical 192Ir and 125I brachytherapy sources

This work establishes a robust, cross-validated computational baseline for brachytherapy dosimetry using general-purpose MC codes under realistic photon emission spectra under realistic, unsimplified photon emission spectra.

Lucas Fabrício de Araújo, Asif Amin, Adriano Sabino et al. · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Comparison of Gonadal Dose Estimation Using Treatment Planning Systems and Monte Carlo Methods in Pelvic Radiotherapy.

INTRODUCTION Unintended irradiation of organs outside the target volume remains a concern in pelvic radiotherapy, particularly for radiosensitive structures such as the gonads. Analytical dose calculation algorithms used in treatment planning systems (TPS) may underestimate out-of-field doses. Monte Carlo (MC) methods...

D. Ribeiro, G. Campos, E. Carolino et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access Oct 2026

Dosimetric comparison of the anisotropic analytical algorithm and Acuros XB for single-fraction cranial stereotactic radiosurgery with a 6 MV flattening filter-free beam

Stereotactic radiosurgery delivers an ablative single-fraction dose to small intracranial targets, and the reported dose depends on the calculation algorithm. This exploratory case series quantified the change in reported dosimetry when plans clinically finalised with the anisotropic analytical algorithm (AAA) were rec...

K. Utitsarn, Thepphithak Watthanasarn, Wirasinee Chaloemchawalit et al. · 0 citations
Sep 2026

Clinical commissioning of a commercial brass GRID collimator for spatially fractionated radiotherapy.

Despite its substantial weight and limited maximum field size, GRID-based SFRT offers straightforward treatment planning, efficient dose delivery, and the potential to enhance tumor control through its characteristic peak-to-valley dose distribution.

R. Yaparpalvi, D. Mynampati, M. Garg et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.