Skip to content
Review

Risk Assessment and Management Tool Use, Implementation Quality and Perceived Effectiveness During Shutdown and Turnaround Maintenance: Evidence from a Nigerian Upstream Petroleum Operator

2026 · International Journal of Latest Technology in Engineering, Management & Applied Science · 0 citations

Abstract

Risk assessment and management (RAM) tools are central to shutdown and turnaround maintenance (STAM), but frequent use does not necessarily demonstrate implementation quality or safety effectiveness. This cross-sectional study analysed respondent-level survey data from 148 STAM professionals in a Nigerian upstream petroleum organisation. Descriptive statistics, Spearman correlations, exploratory factor analysis (EFA), robust multiple regression and Mann-Whitney U incident-group comparisons were applied. JSA (M = 4.53) and toolbox talks (M = 4.35) were used more frequently than HAZOP (M = 2.30) and risk registers (M = 2.27). EFA showed only marginal sampling adequacy (KMO = .610; Bartlett's chi-square(10) = 54.70, p < .001) and a weak two-factor structure, confirming that C1-C5 should not be treated as a strongly unidimensional effectiveness scale. The regression model explained little variance in the composite score (R2 = .031; adjusted R2 = -.018; robust F = 0.62, p = .741), and no predictor was significant. Incident-experienced respondents reported modestly higher JSA use, incident-prevention perceptions and field-implementation perceptions, but the composite effectiveness difference was non-significant. The findings support a compliance-effectiveness paradox: high procedural activity can coexist with weak or inconsistent signals of substantive effectiveness. RAM assurance should therefore combine activity frequency with analytical quality, barrier health, control verification and action closure.

View source

Similar papers

Open access Aug 2026

Analysis of Risk Management Maturity and Risk Governance Using AHP: A Case Study at Pt Pertamina Hulu Energi for the 2020–2025 Period

The upstream oil and gas industry faces complex strategic, operational, financial, and governance risks, making mature risk management essential for organizational resilience and decision-making. This study aims to determine the priority weights of Risk Management Maturity (RMM) indicators and Risk Governance aspects a...

R. Prakoso, A. R. Pudyantoro, A. Rozamuri · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Strategic Management and HRM Development in Fragile Contexts: Evidence from Yemeni Pharmaceutical Manufacturing Companies

Purpose: This study examines the impact of strategic management on human resource management (HRM) development in a fragile state context, where evidence remains scarce. Design/methodology/approach: Drawing on the resource-based view (Barney, 1991), dynamic capabilities theory (Teece et al., 1997), and strategic HRM th...

Abubakr Mohammed Hazam Al-Qutaibi · 0 citations
Review Open access Aug 2026

Stakeholder-Based Risk Priority Assessment of Construction Accident Causes: A Comparative FMEA, RPN and t-Test Analysis

This study presents a quantitative, stakeholder-based assessment of construction accident risks using Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA), Risk Priority Number (RPN), risk-rating comparison and t-test significance analysis. Primary survey data were obtained from 1,250 respondents equally distributed among five con...

Sivapiran Natarajan, M. G · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Risk Management and Auditor Competence Associated with Risk-Based Internal Audit Effectiveness: Audit Quality as Moderator in an Indonesian SOE

This study examines the associations between risk management and auditor competence with risk-based internal audit (RBIA) effectiveness and tests whether audit quality moderates these relationships in an Indonesian state-owned enterprise (SOE) subholding operating in port and maritime services. A sequential explanatory...

D. Kurniawan, Driana Leniwati · 0 citations
Review Open access Aug 2026

Implementation of Health and Safety Management Systems in Construction Projects in Jigawa State, Nigeria: Barriers and Mitigation Measures

Construction remains a critical driver of socio-economic development but continues to be characterised by persistent health and safety failures, particularly in developing contexts. In Jigawa State, Nigeria, HSMS implementation has remained largely ineffective due to systemic organisational, managerial, and institut...

Isabirye B Haruna · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Qualitative Versus Quantitative Risk Assessment in Good Manufacturing Practice (GMP) Audits: How European-Based Auditors Interpret Probability Under International Council for Harmonisation Guideline (ICH) Q9 (R1)

Under ICH Q9 (R1), risk is defined as a function of probability and severity of harm. Although probability may be expressed quantitatively, little empirical evidence exists regarding how EU GMP auditors assess probability in practice. This study explored probability assessment approaches among auditors and the use of q...

Dorna Sheikhi, J. Traulsen · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.