Skip to content
Open access

Systematic evaluation of spatial transcriptomic annotation methods reveals conserved tumor microenvironment programs in NSCLC

Aug 2026 · Frontiers in Bioinformatics · Vol 6 · 0 citations · 49 references
Medicine

TL;DR

This study demonstrates that while no single annotation method is universally optimal, multi-method integration enables the identification of robust multi-layer spatial regulatory programs and provides a more reliable framework for interpreting ST data in complex tumor ecosystems.

Abstract

Introduction Spatial transcriptomics (ST) enables high-resolution mapping of cellular heterogeneity in tumor microenvironments, but downstream cell-type annotation remains highly method-dependent. Methods Here, we systematically evaluated four representative annotation frameworks—Seurat, CARD, RCTD, and SPOTlight—across 45 non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) ST samples from 10×Visium comprising 328,561 spots. We performed a comprehensive cross-method assessment across multiple analytical dimensions, including cell-type composition, inter-method agreement, spatial architecture, cell-cell interaction patterns, and functional pathway activity. Results While all methods captured broad tissue organization, substantial variability emerged in inferred cellular composition, spatial clustering, and functional states. CARD and RCTD demonstrated the highest overall concordance across abundance estimation and spatial structure, whereas Seurat and SPOTlight displayed greater method-specific divergence. Functional analyses further revealed method-specific biological programs, with CARD and RCTD better capturing stromal and myeloid identity. Importantly, beyond these differences, cross-method consensus analysis identified robust spatially conserved biological programs across multiple layers, including gene-level signatures, transcription factor activity, and pathway-level reprogramming characterized by enhanced metabolic and translational activity in tumor-proximal regions. These transcriptional signatures were further supported by independent single-cell RNA sequencing datasets, suggesting their biological relevance. Discussion Overall, our study demonstrates that while no single annotation method is universally optimal, multi-method integration enables the identification of robust multi-layer spatial regulatory programs and provides a more reliable framework for interpreting ST data in complex tumor ecosystems.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Review Sep 2026

Single-cell and spatial transcriptomic technologies for lung cancer tumor microenvironment analysis.

How spatially structured cellular ecosystems, rather than individual cell types, determine therapeutic response and resistance in lung cancer is organized around a single question - and observations that are reproducible across independent cohorts and platforms are explicitly separate from those that remain confined to...

C. Braicu, R. Pîrlog, A. Nutu et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access Aug 2026

Spatial transcriptomic and proteomic approaches for profiling prognostic cell communities in solid tumors.

This review discusses how spatial transcriptomics and proteomics enable extraction of spatial metrics including cell density, proximity, and community-level organization and highlights critical spatial features, including immune cell infiltration patterns and vascular niches that are strongly linked to patient outcomes...

Xia Lei, Xuan Cui, Y. Ni et al. · 0 citations
Aug 2026

Accurate reconstruction of spatial cell type maps and characterization of domain-specific functions based on a gene-aware heterogeneous network.

A gene-aware heterogeneous graph attention network called STGnet is proposed for spatial transcriptomics deconvolution and functional annotation that accurately integrates spatial adjacency, transcriptional similarity, and gene-spot associations within a unified heterogeneous network.

Zi-Lin Li, Zhao-Yang Huang, Yan Li et al. · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Classification of Tumor Spatial Transcriptomics Data and Methods

Spatial transcriptomics technologies combine gene expression profiles with the spatial positions of tissues, providing an unprecedented perspective for dissecting the heterogeneity of the tumor microenvironment. However, tumor tissues are highly heterogeneous, and their discontinuous, sparse, and blurred-boundary featu...

Guan-Xiang Qiu · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

RNA and protein are not interchangeable in single-cell spatial multi-omics

Spatial transcriptomics is increasingly used to infer cellular phenotypes, molecular interactions, and functional tissue organization from RNA, although most of these biological processes are ultimately mediated by proteins. Here, we directly tested the interchangeability of spatial RNA and protein measurements using p...

Sergi Cervilla, D. Grases, Noelia Montesdeoca et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access Oct 2026

Spatiotemporal transcriptomics for tumour microenvironment remodelling in cancer progression and therapy

Abstract Background Spatiotemporal transcriptomics (STT) integrates spatially resolved gene expression with temporal information derived from staged samples, paired treatment specimens, or computational inference, providing a framework for reconstructing tissue‐level dynamics. In the tumour microenvironment (TME), STT...

Ying Kang, Qin-Jing Wang, Si-Qi Xu et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.