Skip to content
Review Open access

The Effect of Educational Institution Differences on the Metacognitive Awareness of Mathematics Education University Students in Indonesia

Sep 2026 · International Journal of Educational Narratives · 0 citations · 44 references

Abstract

Background. Metacognitive awareness concerns how students plan, monitor, and evaluate their thinking during mathematical problem solving. Evidence from Indonesian higher education remains limited, particularly across the two public university systems represented by State Islamic Religious Higher Education Institutions (PTKIN) and State Public Higher Education Institutions (PTUN). Purpose. This study compared the metacognitive awareness of mathematics education students enrolled in PTKIN and PTUN institutions and used lecturer interviews to examine curricular and instructional explanations for the observed pattern. The longer-term aim is to inform curriculum review and metacognitive support across both systems. Method. An explanatory sequential mixed-methods design was used. The quantitative phase involved 746 final-semester mathematics education students from 18 Indonesian institutions (402 from PTKIN and 344 from PTUN) who completed the 52-item Metacognitive Awareness Inventory (MAI). Group means were compared with an independent-samples t-test after assumption checks. Follow-up semi-structured interviews with lecturers and program leaders were organized around curriculum and learning-process themes. Results. The PTKIN and PTUN groups had similar mean scores (5.2434 and 5.2552, respectively), and the independent-samples t-test showed no statistically significant difference, t(744) = -0.061, p = .951. Interview participants described substantial overlap in core mathematics and pedagogy courses and in practices used to support problem solving. Institutional affiliation was the only quantitative grouping variable tested; student-level predictors were not ranked. Conclusion. Administrative affiliation alone did not distinguish students' metacognitive awareness in this sample. Programs in both systems should assess and teach metacognitive processes explicitly instead of treating institutional type as a proxy for students' learning needs.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access Oct 2026

Learning for strengthening scientific literacy of pre-service teachers in elementary education programs

Strengthening scientific literacy among pre-service elementary teachers requires learning experiences that connect scientific reasoning, reflection, problem solving, and communication with pedagogical meaning. This study aimed to develop, implement, and evaluate the EXARIS-PBL framework across different institutional c...

Yanti Fitria, Y. Helsa, P. Susongko et al. · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Empowering High School Students through Differentiated Learning in Economics Education: Evidence from Indonesia’s Independent Curriculum

Background. Economic education is expected not only to improve students’ academic achievement but also to empower learners to become active, independent, and responsible decision-makers. Although differentiated learning has been widely recognized as a learner-centered instructional approach, empirical evidence regardin...

P. Kamalia, Santa Aulia Devi Rachmadhani, R. Kurniawan et al. · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Chinese Undergraduates’ Perceptions of Teaching Quality and Learning Experience in Hungarian Higher Education

This qualitative study examines how Chinese undergraduates in the Sino-Hungarian Government Scholarship Programme understand teaching quality and learning experience in Hungarian higher education. Based on interview materials from seven students studying at six Hungarian universities, the article argues that students d...

Yang Yang, Pang-Yen Chang · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

REACT instructional strategy and secondary school students’ mathematics achievement: Gender inclusivity and implications for distance mathematics education

Persistent difficulties in mathematics achievement highlight the need for instructional approaches that connect abstract concepts with learners’ experiences and promote active engagement. This study examined the effect of the Relating, Experiencing, Applying, Cooperating, and Transferring (REACT) instructional strategy...

A. Asanre, Oluwadayo Taiwo Abiodun, Gbenga Samuel Olusola et al. · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Strengthening Literacy and Higher-Order Thinking Skills Among Elementary School Students Through the Implementation of Problem-Based Learning

This community service activity was motivated by the need to strengthen literacy and higher-order thinking skills in Indonesian language instruction for elementary school students. The activity aimed to improve the literacy and higher-order thinking skills of sixth-grade students at Krapyak Godean Public Elementary Sch...

Murwantara, Ikhlasul Ardi Nugroho, Dwi Mahmud Rizki Riyanto · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Implementation of the Questions Students Have (QSH) Learning Method to Enhance Learning Motivation in Islamic Religious Education (A Classroom Action Research)

This Classroom Action Research (CAR) was conducted in response to the low learning motivation in Islamic Religious Education (IRE) among fifth-grade students at SDN Cipajaran, which was primarily caused by the predominance of conventional teacher-centered instructional methods. The study aimed to examine the effectiven...

Alida Lifia, Delis Sri Maryati · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.