Skip to content
Preprint

Exact Action Values Are Not Enough: Rollout-Verified Reinforcement Fine-Tuning of a Reasoning Model for Multi-Zone VAV Control

Jul 2026 · 0 citations · 50 references
Computer Science Engineering

TL;DR

This work first test whether a frontier reasoning model (an LLM trained to use additional inference-time computation) can achieve competitive VAV control from text without building-specific training, and whether TD3-guided reinforcement fine-tuning (RFT) can transfer control knowledge into a locally deployable open-weight model.

Abstract

Multi-zone variable-air-volume control must balance thermal comfort, indoor air quality, and electricity use across several continuous actuators. Model predictive control and reinforcement learning are widely studied, but deployment typically requires building-specific modeling or training, limiting scalability. We first test whether a frontier reasoning model (an LLM trained to use additional inference-time computation) can achieve competitive VAV control from text without building-specific training. With that capability established, we then test whether TD3-guided reinforcement fine-tuning (RFT) can transfer control knowledge into a locally deployable open-weight model. Five controllers are evaluated over three summer days in a physics-based four-zone emulator. Relative to a Guideline 36-based baseline, TD3 reduced HVAC electricity by 4.5% while improving temperature and CO$_2$ compliance. Without building-specific training, GPT-5 achieved the largest reduction (6.2%) but reduced the ventilation margin. For RFT, deterministic rollouts restore a saved state, apply one candidate, and follow TD3 to score each action. Auditing a learned critic against these rollouts exposed a failure hidden by its near-perfect across-time correlation ($r=0.9998$): within-state ranking was unreliable; the critic selected the rollout-best candidate in only 5 of 10 states. Even with the rollout verifier, 200 RFT steps produced no sustained improvement in sampled-action return; the open-weight controller used more electricity than the baseline before and after training, and its five-minute predictions remained worse than persistence. GPT-5 predicted transitions far better. Exact rollout scores rank sampled actions but reveal neither next-state effects nor an improvement direction. The unchanged transition errors motivate transition-focused supervised fine-tuning before value-based RFT.

View source

Similar papers

Jul 2026

Verifier-Based Reinforcement Fine-Tuning of Reasoning Models for Thermal Energy Storage Control

This study adapts an open-weight reasoning model through reinforcement learning with verifiable rewards (RLVR), which converts exact offline dynamic-programming action values into dense rewards for every candidate action to adapt open-weight reasoning models to building storage scheduling.

Takumi Shioda, Kohei Terashima, T. Nagai · 1 citation
Preprint Jul 2026

Explainable Reinforcement Learning via Physics-Aware Policy Distillation

Comparative control theory analysis reveals a fundamental trade-off: transitioning from continuous to discrete rule-based control induces high-frequency Bang-Bang actuation and a stable bimodal limit cycle.

Shaker Al-Tamari, Waled Kadour · 0 citations
Preprint Jul 2026

Building2Building: A Large Scale Benchmark for Generalizable Real-World Reinforcement Learning

Reinforcement learning (RL) has achieved strong results in control, yet learned policies remain brittle to changes in dynamics, action spaces, observation spaces, or goals, a critical limitation for real-world deployment. Existing benchmarks offer limited diversity and complexity, making it difficult to rigorously study transfer, multi-task learning, and meta-learning in RL. We introduce Building2Building (B2B), a large-scale suite of realistic Heating, Ventilation, and Air Conditioning (HVAC) control environments built on EnergyPlus, a state-of-the-art building simulator. B2B is fully compatible with the Gymnasium interface and features a parametric building generator, enabling the systematic generation of diverse building configurations with heterogeneous observation and action spaces. Based on this suite, we define benchmark tasks targeting key open challenges in RL, including goal adaptation, dynamics adaptation, action-space shifts, and cross-domain transfer. By providing a large-scale, diverse, and physically grounded testbed with standardized evaluation protocols, B2B enables systematic investigation of generalization and transfer in continuous control. Beyond advancing research on generalization in RL, this new benchmark also carries significant societal implications by enabling improved HVAC control at scale, one of the most energy-intensive systems in buildings.

Vincent Taboga, Justine Veilleux, Doseok Jang et al. · 0 citations
Preprint Aug 2026

Efficient Reinforcement Learning for Long-Horizon Tool-Use Agentic Tasks

SINKFLEX-RL, a modular training system for RL in dual-control tool-use environments that combines a Gymnasium-compatible environment wrapper, a VERL-style rollout dataflow, group-relative policy optimization without a separate value model, and a sink-aware FlexAttention path designed to preserve model-specific sink scaling under causal and sliding-window masks is presented.

Zelei Cheng, Amritansh Mishra, Sambit Sahu et al. · 0 citations
Jul 2026

QLPO: Quadrant-weighted Sampling for Length-aware Policy Optimization

Recent large reasoning models often develop long chain-of-thought responses during reinforcement learning (RL), resulting in high inference latency and deployment cost. Existing methods for response length control typically rely on explicit length penalties or additional control modules, which require careful tuning and may compromise reasoning quality. We propose Quadrant-weighted Sampling for Length-aware Policy Optimization (QLPO), a simple resampling-based variant of GRPO that introduces implicit length control without modifying the reward function. QLPO first over-generates candidate responses and then resamples the training group by preserving the empirical correct/incorrect ratio while favoring short correct responses and long incorrect responses. This reshapes the training distribution and implicitly encourages shorter model outputs. Across models ranging from 1.5B to 32B parameters, including both base models and strong reasoning models, QLPO consistently improves the accuracy-length trade-off. It reduces response length by 30% to 70% while preserving reasoning performance. These results suggest that structured resampling provides an effective and robust approach to efficient reasoning.

Siwei Chen, Siqi Chen, Xupeng Miao et al. · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Simulated Corrective Subgoal Supervision for Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning in Long-Horizon AntMaze Navigation

Long-horizon navigation requires a high-level policy to select locally reachable subgoals, yet a scalar task reward provides little information about how an unsuitable proposal should be changed. We introduce Simulated Corrective Subgoal Supervision for Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning (SCS-HRL), a two-level method in which a topology- and clearance-aware programmatic supervisor evaluates each proposed subgoal and returns both a scalar score and a continuous target in the same subgoal space. The score trains the high-level critic, and the target enters a masked regression term for the high-level actor. Primitive actions are always conditioned on the actor’s subgoal; the supervisor is inactive during learned-policy evaluation. In AntMaze, using 6000 training episodes, five seeds, and 100 deterministic evaluation episodes per seed, SCS-HRL attained an 88.4±7.8% final success rate (mean ± sample standard deviation; 95% Student-t confidence interval [78.7%,98.1%]). The matched scalar-only condition and HIRO attained 0% rates. Applying the same route rule directly to the SCS-HRL low-level controllers yielded 82.2±9.9% success; the paired difference favored the learned high-level policy by 6.2 percentage points (95% confidence interval [2.1,10.3], p=0.013). Across three matched seeds, nonzero corrective weights of 0.5, 1.0, and 2.0 remained stable, whereas 0.25 was seed-sensitive. Term-level ablations further show that the continuous target, rather than the exact scalar-shaping formula, was the principal additional signal. Separate fixed-policy tests obtained 0% success rates on two unseen maze layouts. These results indicate that continuous subgoal targets can encode task-specific route information in the source maze, while cross-layout transfer remains unresolved.

Li-Dong Sun, Ye Wang, Zhennan Fan et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.