Author Responses to Problematic Peer Review: A Service Perspective
Abstract
Peer review reports are not always easy to respond to. A report may press for citations the paper does not need, misread what the paper says, or reflect limited subject expertise. Some reports may also raise questions about undisclosed use of artificial intelligence. This letter asks what authors can do in such cases. It calls the problem a peer review service deadlock. The author must protect the integrity of the manuscript but also needs a timely decision. A short table sets out five ways to respond and the likely consequences of each. The letter closes with practical steps for editors and journals.