La coevaluación como herramienta de aprendizaje en enseñanzas superiores
Abstract
This paper presents a teaching innovation experience developed in a course on building systems in public buildings for fourth-year architecture students.The teaching of technical subjects in architecture suffers from tight schedules that require balancing the acquisition of new learning and the development of critical thinking within just a few weeks of instruction. For this reason, assessment opportunities must also be formative.Learning-oriented assessment at the university level requires involving students in participatory evaluation processes (self-assessment, peer assessment, and co-assessment). These participatory actions have been shown to have positive effects on self-regulation, deep learning, and the development of critical thinking in higher education, allowing students to take a more active role in constructing and validating their own knowledge (Campos et al. 2024). This becomes especially relevant in the field of architecture, where the analysis of transversal solutions and technical argumentation are central.The main goal of this experience was to reinforce meaningful learning through a peer assessment methodology in each lecture session, analyzing the impact of this ongoing co-assessment on the development of self-regulated learning competence.The proposal is based on the pedagogical foundations of collaborative learning and formative assessment, fostering critical reflection and shared responsibility in the learning process.The course in which the experience took place is situated in the fourth year of the degree, within the field of Architectural Technology. It is a compulsory subject with both theoretical and practical content and is highly connected to professional practice. The course content focuses on the proposal, technical development, justification, and preliminary sizing of building services for public buildings. The systems to be developed include: fire protection systems, acoustics, artificial lighting, and HVAC. It also offers an initial overview of the integration of all systems in a public building in terms of size and use.The study adopted a quasi-experimental design with a control group and an experimental group, naturalistic in nature, aiming to maximize ecological validity by maintaining the ordinary operating conditions of both the course and the school. Both groups belonged to the same course, taught in the same semester by the same instructor, which allowed control over variability linked to teaching style, grading criteria, and classroom management.In the control group, the ongoing diagnostic and process-based assessment system remained unchanged, based on periodic assessment of individual and group assignments, guided and graded solely by the instructor. In the experimental group, in addition to this scheme, an ongoing co-assessment framework was implemented in which the instructor was joined by two students from different groups to share the responsibility of analyzing and discussing the assignments of a third group during each review session.Thus, the innovation focuses on how assessment is conducted and on the role of students in generating feedback.Before each session, the two peer assessors must prepare two questions related to the theory taught that week, applied to the practical work they are evaluating.To ensure the viability of the proposal, at the beginning of the term an explicit agreement was made with the experimental group that included two basic elements: a minimum attendance commitment and regular attendance of theoretical classes.Both groups maintained the same content, schedule, activities, and summative assessment system, so the independent variable was the mode of formative assessment. The main dependent variables are:· Academic performance· Student perception of the usefulness of corrections: clarity of criteria and clarity of feedback· Participation in the evaluation process· Qualitative evidence on the types of questions asked and the depth of technical discussions.Specific rubrics were used for each thematic block—PCI, acoustics, artificial lighting, and HVAC—which addressed both technical criteria (regulatory compliance, justification of solutions, appropriateness of calculations) and graphic communication and argumentation. In the control group these rubrics were used exclusively by the instructor, whereas in the experimental group they served as a shared reference to guide peer assessors’ questions and structure the discussion.A mobile application was developed that students could access during class to facilitate evaluation and comments on their peers’ work, generating an Excel file that served both for weekly communication with those evaluated and for managing study information.Quantitative results show a slight improvement in course performance, however, qualitative results demonstrate the effectiveness of the methodology regarding the type and depth of questions asked, perceived changes in management of one's own learning, and the transversality exercised by students in applying the content of this subject to other courses during the same year. La evaluación orientada al aprendizaje en la educación superior demanda la participación activa del estudiante para fomentar su autonomía y autorregulación. Este artículo analiza una experiencia de innovación docente basada en la coevaluación continua en la asignatura de Acondicionamiento y Servicios III. El estudio emplea un diseño cuasiexperimental con un grupo de control y un grupo de estudio, en el cual se transformaron las correcciones periódicas en sesiones de evaluación compartida entre la docente y el alumnado. Los resultados demuestran que la coevaluación actúa como un potente factor de motivación, logrando una retención del 100% en el grupo estudio frente al 6,9% de abandono en el grupo control. Asimismo, se observó una mejora cualitativa en el aprendizaje, manifestada en consultas vinculadas a la práctica profesional y la integración interdisciplinar con proyectos arquitectónicos. Se concluye que la coevaluación promueve el desarrollo del juicio evaluativo y la competencia de "aprender a aprender".