Judge's Considerations in Rendering Verdicts Against Children as Perpetrators of Sexual Exploitation Crimes
Abstract
Purpose: This study addresses the gap in the juvenile justice literature regarding minor facilitators in human trafficking networks by analyzing judicial considerations in Decision Number 21/Pid. Sus-Anak/2025/PN Tjk and identifies the underlying factors driving child involvement in sexual exploitation. Research Methodology: An empirical juridical method with a case study design was used. Primary data were gathered through semi-structured interviews with a presiding judge, public prosecutor, and police investigator, supplemented by a secondary analysis of statutory regulations and court records. Results: The findings reveal that judicial considerations integrated juridical elements (offense fulfillment, physical evidence, and witness testimonies) with non-juridical factors (offender's age, psychological state, and Bapas social inquiry reports). Law enforcement decisions balanced legal accountability with child welfare. Child participation in sexual exploitation was driven by multidimensional internal vulnerabilities (limited legal awareness, emotional immaturity, and economic motivation) and external pressures (family dysfunction, negative peer influences, and digital adult content exposure). Conclusions: Judges’ considerations reflect an effort to balance legal certainty with the protection and best interests of the child, rather than relying solely on a retributive approach. The causes of child involvement in sexual exploitation are multidimensional, requiring a collaborative prevention approach involving the family, community, and law enforcement. Limitations: Constrained by its single-case design within one jurisdiction, the empirical insights may not fully reflect cases with distinct socioeconomic or procedural contexts. Contributions: This study advances the juvenile criminal law discourse by offering empirical insights from legal practitioners and practical framework recommendations for handling complex child perpetrator cases.