Skip to content
Open access

Integrated Waste Treatment Facility In Payakumbuh: Performance Evaluation and Technology Selection Using Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis

Oct 2026 · International Journal of Science, Technology & Management · 0 citations · 28 references

Abstract

The collapse of the Payakumbuh regional landfill in December 2023 left the city without a final disposal site, so the integrated waste treatment facility (TPST) commissioned in January 2025 now carries most of the municipal waste load. This study measured the facility's performance, traced its material flows, and identified the most suitable technology combination for its expansion. Performance was assessed with Key Performance Indicators (KPI) covering technical operation, environment, institutions, community participation, and financing, based on direct weighing, three months of operating logs, smoke opacity observation, and interviews. Technology selection applied Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) with the Simple Additive Weighting (SAW) method to five alternatives and nine criteria weighted by four experts. The overall KPI score was only 28% (poor). Productivity and process efficiency were both 27.31%, and the treatment cost reached IDR 720,479 per tonne. The mass balance showed that manual sorting removed only 3.25% of the incoming waste, while 52.02% ended up in the pyrolysis–gasification unit. To close a capacity gap of 71.5 t/day, the combination of mechanical sorting, rotary kiln composting, and conversion of low-value inorganic waste into Refuse-Derived Fuel (RDF) achieved the highest score (0.7557), followed by the option using pyrolysis–gasification (0.7356). The three highest ranks did not change when the weights of the three most important criteria were each reduced by 10%. These findings indicate that upstream sorting and diversion of the inorganic fraction to RDF matter more to facility performance than additional thermal capacity.

Read PDF

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.