Balancing electron flux in iron-sulfur constructed wetlands: A thermodynamic-metabolic perspective on stable nitrogen removal.
Abstract
Constructed wetlands (CWs) are sustainable platforms for wastewater treatment, but their denitrification performance is often constrained under low carbon-to-nitrogen (C/N) conditions by insufficient organic electron donors. Autotrophic denitrification driven by sulfur (S)-based and iron (Fe)-based materials offers a promising route to overcome this limitation, yet single-donor systems are affected by inherent trade-offs. S-based substrates, including elemental sulfur and pyrite, can support nitrate reduction but may cause acidification and sulfate accumulation. Fe-based substrates present different constraints: zero-valent iron is susceptible to surface passivation and may favor nitrate reduction to ammonium (NH₄⁺-N), whereas steel slag may exhibit variable composition, metal release, excessive pH, and clogging. Recent efforts have therefore turned to integrated multi-donor substrates, particularly pyrite-steel slag composites, which can couple electron release, pH buffering and byproduct control through Fe-S-N biogeochemical interactions. However, why highly reactive Fe-S substrates do not always sustain long-term nitrogen removal in CWs remains insufficiently understood. Here, we synthesize recent advances in S-based, Fe-based, and composite electron donors and propose a thermodynamic-metabolic perspective for interpreting their performance. We compare their electron-supplying capacity, ion-release behavior, pH regulation, passivation tendency, and nitrogen-product selectivity, and argue that standard reaction Gibbs energy, release kinetics, and microbial metabolic capacity should be evaluated together when balancing electron flux, rather than using substrate reactivity alone as the design criterion. We further highlight how atomic-scale descriptors, including adsorption energy and surface electronic structure, may support future rational design of Fe-S composites when linked to wetland-scale nitrogen removal and water-quality outcomes. This review provides a mechanistic framework for shifting CW substrate design from empirical optimization toward a robust, sustainable, and mechanism-guided approach to nitrogen removal.