An Integrated Neutrosophic–Fuzzy MCDM Framework Through Employing the Evidence-Based Weighting and Robust Ranking
Abstract
This study proposed a new integrated decision framework that combined neutrosophic modeling, fuzzy representation, and multicriteria decision-making to produce an objective, transparent, and robust evaluation process for physical education teaching quality. The core idea was to represent each evaluation indicator using a neutrosophic triple that separated supportive evidence, indeterminate evidence, and opposing evidence, while fuzzy terms were used to capture gradual transitions in human judgments. Based on these representations, the study designed a two-stage weighting scheme that balanced evidence consistency across experts with data-driven dispersion across indicators, reducing the influence of biased or unstable opinions. Then, a robust ranking mechanism was introduced to compare teaching units against a clearly defined reference profile, producing an interpretable overall score and a final ranking. A complete case study was provided on university physical education teaching quality.