THE PROBLEM OF NOTARIAL LEGAL LIABILITY FOR DISPUTED AUTHENTIC DEEDS
Abstract
Abstract A notary is a public official holding authority to make an authentic deed, an instrument of written evidence carrying perfect evidentiary force. Notwithstanding the strategic position that standing confers, an authentic deed made by a notary not infrequently becomes the object of dispute before the court, raising a fundamental question regarding the limit and form of notarial legal liability for the deed disputed. This article examines the regulation of notarial legal liability for a disputed authentic deed under the Notarial Office Law and related legislation, together with the limit of notarial legal liability for the formal and material truth of a disputed authentic deed in judicial practice. Employing a normative legal method with statutory and conceptual approaches, the study finds that the Notarial Office Law does not explicitly regulate the formulation of notarial liability where a deed is disputed, generating broad interpretive latitude in law-enforcement practice, and that judicial practice shows an inconsistent tendency to extend a notary's liability beyond the formal truth for which the notary is properly responsible into the material truth of the parties' own statement, a tendency the article argues reflects a conflation of two analytically distinct forms of evidentiary weight requiring firmer doctrinal separation, informed by comparative and empirical scholarship on the structural driver of this liability-extension pattern.