Perceptions and Requirements of Data-Driven Performance Management Platforms in Higher Education
Abstract
This study aimed to analyze university members' perceptions and requirements regarding data-driven performance management platforms in higher education and to explore directions for improving and advancing such platforms in the future. To this end, a survey was conducted with 141 participants, including faculty members, administrative staff, and industry-academic cooperation personnel working at universities in Korea, and the collected data were analyzed using frequency analysis, descriptive statistics, weighted priority analysis, paired-samples t-tests, importance-performance analysis (IPA), and job-category difference tests. First, although universities used integrated systems for performance management, they still relied on a fragmented structure in which manual documents, Excel-based management, and department-specific systems were used simultaneously. Second, current performance management methods were evaluated relatively positively in terms of ease of data entry, but were found to be insufficient in providing inter-university comparative information, data analysis functions, and usability for decision-making. Third, the primary purpose of managing performance data was concentrated on responding to government-funded projects and institutional evaluations, while functions supporting internal quality improvement and strategic decision-making were relatively insufficient. Fourth, the analysis of platform function requirements showed that the perceived importance of all 15 functional items was significantly higher than their current level of performance, with the largest gaps found in multidimensional performance analysis, predictive analytics, KPI achievement monitoring, automated report generation, and industry-academic cooperation performance tracking. Fifth, the IPA results identified industry-academic cooperation performance tracking, predictive analytics, and multidimensional performance analysis as areas requiring concentrated improvement, and job-category difference tests showed no significant differences in the perceived need for improvement in these areas among faculty/researchers, student-support administrative staff, and IT/information-systems staff, indicating that the findings were not biased toward any single occupational group. These findings suggest that data-driven performance management platforms in higher education need to evolve beyond simple data entry and reporting systems into intelligent platforms that support integrated performance management, real-time monitoring, multidimensional analysis, and prediction-based decision-making, and this study has practical significance in that it presents priorities and practical considerations for the development of university performance management platforms.