Skip to content
Open access

Quining qualia again. Ten reasons

Nov 2026 · Frontiers in Psychology · Vol 17 · 0 citations · 31 references

Abstract

Qualia have long occupied a central place in the science and philosophy of consciousness, often invoked as the subjective residue that eludes physical explanation. In this paper, we argue that the classical concept faces serious explanatory and ontological difficulties. We present 10 reasons for setting it aside: (1) its unstable causal status; (2) the regress of the inner observer; (3) the absence of a determinate neuroscientific target; (4) the lack of autonomous empirical evidence for a quale as such; (5) its epistemic redundancy and duplication of properties already attributed to the world; (6) the reflexive architecture that makes experience available in a first-person format; (7) the limits and reconstructive character of introspection; (8) linguistic reification; (9) the apparent immediacy of experience; and (10) the persistence of residual dualist pictures. We do not deny that experiences occur, differ qualitatively, and are undergone from a first-person point of view. We reject the stronger interpretation of those differences as intrinsic, ineffable, immediately self-revealing, and metaphysically private properties located in an inner mental domain.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access Oct 2026

The Mind Does Not Make Jumps

Bertrand Russell's notion of acquaintance—still influential in contemporary philosophy of mind and epistemology—promises an immediate and epistemically secure awareness of things, independent of conceptualization, predication, and other forms of cognitive activity. This paper reconstructs and assesses the largely neg...

Jacopo Pallagrosi · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Imagination or Reason? A Spinozist Criterion for Genuine Analogical Reasoning in Large Language Models

When Webb, Holyoak, and Lu reported that large language models (LLMs) solve a wide range of analogy problems zero-shot, they reopened an old philosophical question: do such systems reason relationally, or do they exploit surface regularities absorbed from training? Critics show that performance degrades on counterfactu...

Abdurrazak Gültekin · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Cognitive Psychiatry and Operational Necessity: A cognitive reconstruction of the analytic, the synthetic and the necessary in light of recent literature

The analytic-synthetic distinction, from Kant to Carnap, Quine, Goodman and Davidson, remains tied to open questions about necessity and the a priori. We argue that part of the difficulty arises because inquiry has focused on the products of cognition (concepts, propositions, formal systems) rather than on the cognitiv...

Giovanna Azevedo Rodrigues, M. Caixeta · 1 citation
2026

Die (Mit)Denkende Maschine

In retrospect, the 2020s may well be remembered as the decade in which machines learnt to think. Moreover: Sherlock Holmes does not practise the ‘science of deduction’, as he himself claims, but rather that of abduction. What sounds like an introduction to two entirely different subject areas is linked by a central que...

Chris Sawall · 0 citations
Open access 2026

Concepts of Bareness (Nuditas) in Medieval Philosophy

The Aristotelian idiom, according to which the intellect is a “blank” or “bare slate” before it has experienced the sensory world was also used in empiricist arguments during the Middle Ages. In this short inquiry, I examine the use of the adjective bare (or naked) in both epistemology and metaphysics, focusing on four...

E. Lukacs · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Husserl on Cartesian Evidence: A Textual and Phenomenological Reappraisal

Abstract Following Descartes, Husserl assigns a pivotal epistemological, methodological, and ethical role to evidence within the framework of his radical rationalism. At the same time, however, he repeatedly criticizes Descartes’ theory of evidence, on two principal counts. First, he rejects what he takes to be Descart...

Alexis Delamare · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.