Contingent adoption of strategic management accounting in SMEs: The moderating role of organizational conditions
Abstract
Despite its strong theoretical appeal, strategic management accounting (SMA) continues to exhibit limited and uneven adoption in practice, giving rise to what has been termed the “SMA paradox”. This study addresses this tension by conceptualizing SMA not as a standalone set of techniques, but as a context-dependent and systemically embedded managerial practice (Hadid & Al-Sayed, 2021). Drawing on contingency theory, an integrated framework is developed to examine how contextual pressures—namely competitive intensity, environmental uncertainty, and product diversification—interact with organizational conditions and management accounting networks to shape SMA adoption. Using survey data from small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) in Vietnam and applying the partial least squares approach (PLS-SEM), the findings reveal that while contextual factors primarily generate the demand for SMA, its effective adoption depends critically on the presence of enabling organizational conditions and strong accounting networks. These results provide a more nuanced explanation for the fragmented uptake of SMA and highlight the importance of viewing SMA as an organizational process rather than a purely technical tool, offering new insights into how SMEs in emerging economies can better leverage accounting information for strategic decision-making.