A Thematic Analysis of Game-Based Learning Frameworks: Synthesising Pedagogical, Technological, and Design Dimensions
Abstract
Although game-based learning (GBL) has become a very significant approach in teaching, there is no single synthesis of its sub-units. A six-phase thematic analysis is used to find the structural and pedagogical aspects in GBL frameworks in this study, using 24 peer-reviewed sources from the IEEE journals, Scopus-indexed journals, and conference proceedings. The seven recurring themes were found to be: Engagement and Motivation, Pedagogy and Learning Theory, Game Design Mechanics, Adaptive Learning, Technology Integration, Assessment and Feedback, and Critical Thinking and Problem-Solving. These themes were then conceptually combined into the proposed GATE-GBL model (Game-based Adaptive Thematic Engagement for Learning) that illustrates the relationship between design, technology and pedagogy within GBL environments. Importantly, the analysis shows that while all frameworks explicitly discuss the issues of engagement and game mechanics, adaptive learning, assessment over time and critical thinking are less developed. The results offer a research-based framework for developing effective, student-centered educational games and offer specific suggestions for engineering contexts.