Skip to content
Open access

Ecological context shapes the interpretation of biodiversity intactness metrics

Oct 2026 · bioRxiv · 0 citations
Biology

Abstract

Developing biodiversity metrics that are both operational for decision-making and ecologically meaningful remains challenging. Mean Species Abundance (MSA) is widely used to quantify biodiversity intactness in applications including biodiversity scenario modeling, spatial assessment, policy and planning, and life cycle assessment (LCA). MSA compares species abundance under disturbed conditions with their abundance under a reference condition, but the pressure–impact relationships used to calculate it are generalized across studies and may not adequately represent variation among ecological contexts or taxonomic groups. This is particularly relevant when MSA is transferred across regions or used to support comparisons and environmental decision-making. We compiled biodiversity data from 7,064 forest fragments containing 21,761 species of arthropods, amphibians, birds, mammals, squamates, and plants across 11 biomes worldwide. We evaluated how MSA relates to broader ecological outcomes, including local and regional species richness and ecosystem productivity, and whether these relationships vary across ecological contexts (vegetation condition, landscape structure, and biome) and taxonomic groups. MSA was positively associated with local species richness and ecosystem productivity across all sites, but these associations weakened, disappeared, or reversed depending on ecological context and taxonomic group. For example, the MSA–productivity association held in only five of 11 biomes, and the MSA–regional richness association was negative in temperate conifer and boreal forests but positive in four other biomes. We propose a simple decision guide linking assessment goals, contextual evaluation, and interpretation to help identify when MSA can be used directly, when ecological context should guide its interpretation, and when complementary ecological information is needed. These findings may extend to other biodiversity metrics that compare impacted conditions with reference states and apply generalized impact relationships across ecological contexts and taxonomic groups.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Review Open access

The Many Faces of Biodiversity: Climate-Driven Forest Reassembly Across Ecological Scales

Climate change is rapidly reshaping ecosystems worldwide, forcing species to shift their distributions and driving profound compositional and functional changes in ecological communities. These changes are neither uniform nor monotonous across biomes, spatial scales, taxa, time frames, and methodological approaches, re...

I. Shabanov · 0 citations
Open access

Assembling the jigsaw puzzle of biodiversity–ecosystem stability relationships

Biodiversity loss and climate change threaten the long-term stability of ecosystem functioning and the ecosystem services upon which human societies depend. Understanding how biodiversity stabilizes ecosystem functioning has therefore become one of the central challenges in ecology. Although it is widely recognized tha...

Xiao-Bin Pan · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

Informing afforestation decisions with expert knowledge on forest biodiversity

Biodiversity underpins the ecosystem services provided by forests, yet for several planting scenarios expected to play an increasing role in future afforestation, the absence of comparable biodiversity data constrains ecosystem service modelling, natural capital accounting and associated economic valuation, thereby lim...

Kate Harrington, Fraser J. G. Mitchell, Mary Ryan et al. · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Predicting Species-Area Relationships in Fragmented Forests

Habitat destruction leads to a severe decline in biodiversity. Ascertaining effects of habitat loss afterwards is regularly done, whereas predicting the effects of different habitat loss scenarios on biodiversity beforehand is much preferred but as of yet rarely possible. Such predictions would help inform management d...

Monique de Jager, Finn J. van Wordragen, Fleur Vrouwenvelder-Slegers et al. · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Uneven research attention to biodiversity loss revealed by large language models

Biological diversity is crucial for ecosystem functioning and human well-being but is declining under multiple pressures from human activity. Research on biodiversity loss spans multiple ecological contexts, yet existing syntheses typically cover only subsets of the evidence base. We developed a systematic mapping fram...

Hunain Mohiuddin, Kerstin Forster, S. Feuerriegel · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.