Skip to content
Open access

The Legal Status and Reliability of Digital Evidence in the Criminal Justice System Under Law No. 20 of 2025: Risks of Miscarriage of Justice

Sep 2026 · UMPurwokerto Law Review · 0 citations

Abstract

The development of information technology has transformed the criminal justice process, particularly the use of digital evidence in proving criminal cases. Digital evidence may provide important information concerning an alleged criminal event, but its characteristics also make it vulnerable to copying, modification, and manipulation. This study examines the legal position of electronic evidence in the Indonesian criminal evidence system under Law Number 20 of 2025 concerning the Criminal Procedure Code and analyzes whether the regulation is sufficient to guarantee the authenticity and reliability of digital evidence so as to reduce the risk of Miscarriage of Justice. This research uses normative juridical analysis with a statutory and conceptual approach. The study relies on secondary legal materials consisting of legislation, legal literature, and relevant scientific publications. The findings indicate that electronic evidence has been recognized as a legitimate component of the criminal evidence system. Nevertheless, normative recognition is not fully accompanied by detailed procedural standards concerning authentication, digital forensic examination, and chain of custody. This gap creates challenges in ensuring that digital evidence presented in court accurately reflects the underlying facts. Manipulated digital evidence may affect the assessment of evidence and the formation of judicial conviction, thereby creating a risk of erroneous adjudication. Strengthening procedural standards, digital forensic capacity, and traceable evidence-management procedures is therefore relevant to maintaining the integrity of digital evidence in criminal proceedings.

Read PDF

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.