The legal framework of artificially intelligent bills of lading: Contractual validity and enforceability in a digital environment
Abstract
The progressive digitalisation of international trade and the emergence of artificial intelligence (AI) in maritime transport raise fundamental questions concerning the legal status, contractual validity, and enforceability of AI-generated bills of lading. This article examines whether an AI-generated bill of lading may function as a constitutive contract of carriage and a negotiable instrument, and under what legal conditions such a document is valid and enforceable across jurisdictions. The central problem addressed is the absence of a coherent, internationally harmonized legal framework capable of governing AI-generated transport documents, particularly in light of the fully autonomous, human-free issuance facilitated by modern AI platforms. Employing a comparative doctrinal methodology, the article analyses the legal treatment of the bill of lading as a contract of carriage under United States law and Greek law, and examines the regulatory frameworks applicable to AI-generated documents in the United Kingdom - notably the Electronic Trade Documents Act 2023 - and the European Union, with particular focus on the EU AI Act. The article further traces the historical development of the bill of lading as a standardized adhesion contract and negotiable instrument, and assesses the implications of AI-driven tokenisation for trade finance. It is concluded that whilst both the UK and the EU have taken meaningful steps towards accommodating electronic and AI-generated trade documents, significant legal gaps persist, particularly regarding compliance with documentary credit requirements under UCP 600. The article advances normative proposals for the development of an internationally harmonised legal framework under the auspices of UNCTAD, the ICC, and the IMO.