STRAINED YET CONNECTED: A BIVARIATE ANALYSIS OF THE DUAL ASSOCIATION BETWEEN DIGITAL DISRUPTION AND WELLBEING AMONG UNDERGRADUATE YOUTH IN PUNJAB, PAKISTAN
Abstract
The wellbeing effects of digital disruption on youth have most often been reported either as uniformly harmful or as uniformly beneficial, an aggregation that obscures the dual character of a condition experienced by young people as both straining and connecting. This paper reports a bivariate analysis of survey data collected from six hundred Bachelor of Studies-level students at public-sector universities in urban Punjab, Pakistan, focusing on the associations among a composite digital disruption construct, social isolation, perceived digital inequality and three wellbeing outcomes: physical health impact, psychological distress and digital social connectedness. One-sample t-tests against the neutral midpoint documented that digital technology had improved perceived access to educational resources by more than one standard deviation (d = 1.11), while perceived economic benefit was small (d = 0.14). Pearson correlations showed that the digital disruption composite was moderately and significantly associated with all three wellbeing outcomes (r = .40 to .43), producing a distinctive dual pattern in which the same predictor correlated positively with perceived strain and with digitally enabled social connection. Welch’s t-tests found no significant gender differences on any focal variable. One-way analyses of variance across urban, semi-urban and rural areas produced a single significant difference on psychological distress, with rural respondents scoring higher than urban respondents (Games-Howell Δ = 0.23, p = .014). Comparisons across four household income bands and between respondents with and without home internet were non-significant, and chi-square tests of association across dichotomised groupings were likewise non-significant. Perceptions of digital inequality by urban-rural residence were widespread (d = 0.79) yet did not correspond to measured differences in reported digital media influence. The findings support a dual account of digital disruption, expose a substantive divergence between perceived and measured inequality and contribute a Pakistani case to the international literature on digital youth wellbeing.