Skip to content
Open access

Comparative Analysis of the SMART and MFEP Methods for Selecting Baking Ingredient Suppliers for Bakery MSMEs in East Bekasi District

Sep 2026 · Journal of Artificial Intelligence and Technology Information (JAITI) · 0 citations · 17 references

Abstract

The selection of raw material suppliers is one of the key factors in maintaining product quality and operational efficiency for Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) in the bakery industry. Supplier selection processes that are still conducted subjectively have the potential to cause problems such as inconsistent material quality, delayed deliveries, and increased operational costs. This study aims to analyze and compare the performance of the Simple Multi-Attribute Rating Technique (SMART) and the Multifactor Evaluation Process (MFEP) methods in supporting decision-making for the selection of baking ingredient suppliers for bakery MSMEs in East Bekasi District. The research employed a comparative quantitative approach, with data collected through observations, interviews, and questionnaires administered to five bakery MSME owners. The evaluation was based on five main criteria: base price, material quality, delivery timeliness, service quality, and payment term flexibility. The collected data were then processed using the SMART and MFEP methods to generate preference scores and supplier rankings. The results indicate that both methods consistently identified the best supplier, namely alternative S1, with a SMART score of 0.845 and an MFEP score of 8.25. Differences in ranking were found among the middle alternatives, indicating variations in the sensitivity of the calculations between the two methods. The SMART method produced rankings that were more responsive to changes in criterion weights due to its linear utility approach, whereas the MFEP method tended to provide more stable results through direct weighted factor evaluation. Based on these findings, the SMART method is more suitable for dynamic supply chain environments, while the MFEP method is better applied in relatively stable and standardized evaluation conditions.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access Sep 2026

Selection of The Best Soybean Supplier for Tempe Balap MSME using The Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) Method

Tempe Balap MSME is a tempe production business that is highly dependent on the availability of soybean raw materials. Frequent problems include late deliveries and uncertainty about the availability of soybean stocks from suppliers, which can disrupt the smooth production process. Furthermore, supplier selection has b...

Sucy Wahcyuni A, D. S. Utomo, R. Asdi · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

A Decision Support System for Recommending Authentic Sweet Tuak Using the AHP (Analytical Hierarchy Process) Method

Technological development has shifted the assessment of food and beverage quality from a subjective process toward a more systematic and objective one. Tuak manis, a traditional sweet palm-sap beverage from Tamansari Village, West Lombok, Indonesia, is still evaluated subjectively, resulting in inconsistent quality jud...

Widia Wati, S. Sunardi, Helmy Amalia Ariesta et al. · 0 citations
Open access Dec 2026

The Effect Of Price, Packaging, And Product Quality On The Purchase Decision Of Msme Products (Case Study Of Palm Souvenir Shops In Lubuklinggau City)

MSME souvenir products are one of the local business sectors that help support regional economic growth by offering products that represent the unique characteristics of an area and are often purchased as gifts or souvenirs. To remain competitive and continue growing, MSME businesses need to understand consumer needs a...

Muhammad Geri Aji Pratama, Endar Pradesa, Ratih Eka Sakti · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Analysis of Food and Beverage MSMEs' Readiness in Fulfilling Halal Certification to Improve Business Competitiveness

This study aims to analyze the readiness and constraints of Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) in the food and beverage sector in Serang City in fulfilling halal certification requirements and to examine the role of technical assistance in supporting the certification process. A descriptive qualitative approa...

Elis Badariah, Mel Sandra, Ahmad Solihin et al. · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Selection of Blue Swimming Crab Meat Suppliers Using The Method Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) and Technique For Order Preference By Similarity To Ideal Solution (TOPSIS) In PT XYZ

PT XYZ is a business entity operating in the marine product processing sector, with pasteurized canned crab meat as its flagship product. Selecting a raw material supplier of crab meat requires the consideration of several criteria to ensure that the chosen supplier can consistently meet the company's raw material requ...

Adinda Cahya Fitriani, A. Rizqi, Purwanto · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Porter’s Five Forces Analysis for MSME Development Strategies; A Case Study of the Bakso Meletup MSME

This study aims to analyze the competitive environment and formulate development strategies for the Bakso Meletup micro, small, and medium enterprise (MSME) using Porter’s Five Forces framework. This research employed a descriptive qualitative approach, with informants selected purposively, including the business owner...

Dinda Sabila Salwa, Paisal, Andriansyah Bari · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.