Skip to content
Review Open access

A Meta-Analysis on the Effectiveness of Problem-Based Learning on Students’ Cognitive Outcomes in Chemistry Education

2026 · International journal of research and innovation in social science · 0 citations

Abstract

Problem-based learning has been widely recognized as a learner-centered instructional approach for developing students' cognitive outcomes in chemistry education, but empirical findings on its effectiveness remain inconsistent, specifically in different regions, educational levels, and specific chemistry topics. In this meta-analysis, 14 experimental and quasi-experimental peer-reviewed studies from 2017-2026 were synthesized from six databases (ERIC, Cross-Reference (CrossRef), Google Scholar, ProQuest, OpenAlex, and ResearchGate) to determine the overall impact of PBL on students' cognitive outcomes in chemistry education compared to conventional methods and to examine how this effect differs based on the type of cognitive outcome level: academic achievement and higher-order thinking skills; continental location: Africa versus Asia & Middle East; and class size. The effect sizes were calculated grounded on the posttest means, standard deviations, and sample sizes from the combined total of 1,299 participants using Meta-Essentials v. 1.5. Findings showed that PBL had a large, statistically significant pooled effect compared to the conventional method (Hedges’ g = 1.18, 95% CI [0.69, 1.68], p < .001), although high heterogeneity was observed across the studies (I² = 90.98%), which led to further subgroup and moderator analyses. Subgroup analyses showed that cognitive outcome level and continental location did not significantly moderate this effect, indicating that PBL produced comparable benefits across both outcome types and both regions. Likewise, class size was not a significant moderator (p = .572). Assessment of publication bias using Trim-and-Fill and Egger’s regression test found no significant evidence of bias. These findings suggest that PBL is broadly and consistently effective in improving students’ cognitive outcomes in chemistry education, regardless of outcome type, regional context, or class size, although the high residual heterogeneity indicates that implementation should still be tailored to specific instructional contexts.

Read PDF

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.