Layer-Wise Analysis of Lightweight Cryptographic Protocols for IoT Security: A Threat-Driven Survey and LACSS-Based Evaluation Framework
Abstract
The rapid growth of Internet of Things (IoT) devices has created major security challenges across different application environments, particularly because many IoT devices operate with limited computing power, memory, and energy resources. Lightweight Cryptography (LWC) has emerged as an effective approach for securing such resource constrained devices. However, most existing studies focus primarily on performance metrics such as execution speed, memory usage, and energy consumption, while providing limited analysis of how these algorithms address security threats across different layers of the IoT architecture. This paper presents a layer wise and threat oriented survey of Lightweight Cryptographic protocols across four key IoT layers: Perception, Network, Middleware, and Application. For each layer, common security threats are identified and the suitability of five widely used LWC algorithms, namely PRESENT, SIMON, SPECK, GIFT, and the NIST standardized ASCON, is evaluated. The paper introduces two main contributions. First, a Layer Threat Algorithm Mapping Matrix (LTAMM) is proposed to systematically map security threats at each IoT layer with appropriate cryptographic solutions. Second, a Protocol Selection Framework is developed to support context aware algorithm selection based on deployment requirements. To enable quantitative comparison, a Layer Aware Cryptographic Suitability Score (LACSS) is calculated for all algorithms using multiple evaluation criteria. The results indicate that ASCON provides the most balanced combination of security and performance across all four IoT layers, while SIMON and SPECK remain suitable choices for hardware constrained and software focused environments respectively.