Value-Added Tax Incentives and Green Innovation: Unintended Consequences in China’s New Energy Industry
Abstract
Emerging economies’ new energy sectors have made extensive use of tax incentives. However, it is unclear how effective these incentives work to encourage firms’ green innovation. This study uses the difference-in-difference (DID) methodology to investigate the impact of Value-added Tax (VAT) incentives on green innovation, using a dataset of 16,477 firm-year observations from China’s new energy sector spanning the years 2003 to 2012. We find that VAT incentives significantly reduce firms’ green innovation, measured by the total number of green patent applications (log-transformed), by approximately 5.5%. This reveals a paradox: while intended to promote green development, VAT incentives might inadvertently suppress green innovation and encourage low-quality scale expansion. Further analysis shows that this scale expansion exerts a substitution effect on green innovation, without generating a significant output effect due to the lack of profitability improvements. Heterogeneity analysis suggests that the detrimental effects of scale expansion on green innovation can be mitigated by strengthening enterprises’ internal innovation capabilities and boosting the external innovation environment.