Skip to content
Review Open access

How Often Do Pharmacists End up in Court? Analysis of Civil and Criminal Case Law in Poland

Sep 2026 · Healthcare · Vol 14, pp. 2861 · 0 citations · 18 references
Medicine

TL;DR

The findings demonstrate that legal proceedings involving pharmacists are not isolated events but represent a recurring phenomenon within professional practice, and highlight the need for greater legal awareness among pharmacists, enhanced risk-management education, and stronger integration of legal competencies into undergraduate and postgraduate pharmacy training.

Abstract

Background: Pharmacists, as healthcare professionals of public trust, operate within a complex legal environment involving multiple forms of professional liability, particularly civil and criminal liability. Although these forms of responsibility are formally regulated by statutory law, the practical distinction between them remains largely dependent on judicial interpretation and case-specific circumstances. Objective: The aim of this study was to assess the scale and nature of judicial proceedings involving pharmacists and to identify the most common factors leading to civil and criminal liability. Additionally, the study sought to highlight the largely under-recognized phenomenon of legal actions involving pharmacists and to determine which areas of pharmacy practice generate the greatest legal risk. Methods: The study employed a mixed-methods design combining qualitative case law analysis with descriptive quantitative assessment. A total of 146 judicial decisions involving pharmacists were reviewed, including 43 civil and 19 criminal cases constituting the principal subject of the analysis. The examined judgments were assessed with regard to factual background, legal qualification, judicial reasoning, applied legal provisions, and type of liability imposed. Cases were additionally categorized according to the nature of the violation and the protected legal interest affected. Results: A total of 146 judicial decisions involving pharmacists were identified and analyzed, including 43 civil cases and 19 criminal cases. The findings demonstrate that legal proceedings involving pharmacists are not isolated events but represent a recurring phenomenon within professional practice. Civil cases were dominated by disputes related to reimbursement claims, prescription processing, and regulatory compliance, accounting for over half of all analyzed civil proceedings. In contrast, criminal cases were less frequent but displayed substantial heterogeneity, including unlawful medicine distribution, reimbursement fraud, breaches of professional duties, and other criminal offences. Importantly, only a minority of cases involved direct patient harm, while the majority arose from administrative, organizational, and regulatory obligations associated with pharmacy practice. The analysis identified prescription reimbursement procedures, medicine dispensing regulations, and pharmacy management responsibilities as the principal sources of legal risk for pharmacists. Conclusions: Published case law demonstrates the recurrent presence and considerable diversity of legal proceedings involving pharmacists. Most cases do not arise from direct patient harm but rather from regulatory, administrative, and organizational obligations associated with pharmacy practice. Civil proceedings are predominantly linked to reimbursement and prescription-related disputes, whereas criminal cases are less common but more diverse in nature. The results highlight the need for greater legal awareness among pharmacists, enhanced risk-management education, and stronger integration of legal competencies into undergraduate and postgraduate pharmacy training. Increased recognition of legal risks may contribute to both professional protection and improved patient safety.

Read PDF

Similar papers

ความรับผิดทางอาญาของเจ้าพนักงาน : ศึกษากรณีเจ้าพนักงานที่มีข้อบกพร่องในกระบวนการแต่งตั้ง

This individual study primarily aims to analyze the definition and scope of the term “official” (or “public officer”) under Section 1 (16) of the Criminal Code, as well as the legal issues concerning the criminal liability of officials whose appointment processes are defective but who in fact exercise authoritative...

วรรณกร เฟื่องคอน · 0 citations
Review Open access Oct 2026

Hospital Civil Liability for Healthcare Worker Negligence in Indonesia: A Systematic Review of Doctrinal Gaps and Reliance-Based Accountability

Hospital civil liability for healthcare worker negligence constitutes a central and contested issue in Indonesian health law, particularly following the enactment of Law Number 17 of 2023 concerning Health. Article 193 of this Law imposes institutional liability on hospitals for all losses caused by the negligence of t...

Ai Gunarsih, Robiansah, Handry Mewaldin et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

The application of criminal and administrative liability to minors: Challenges facing the contemporary legal system

It has become especially important under martial law to provide an effective legal response to offences committed by young people at the same time as maintaining the humane principles of juvenile justice. This article aimed to evaluate the mechanisms responsible for the criminal and administrative liability of minors a...

N. Parasiuk, O. Onyshko, Kostovska Kateruna et al. · 0 citations
Book Open access 2022

A Swedish perspective

The Swedish legal system belongs to the family of civil law and its primary source of law is statutory law. Criminal cases are decided by the general courts (district courts, courts of appeal, and the Supreme court), whereas cases concerning coercive mental health care are decided by the administrative courts. In addit...

Tova Bennet, M. Hildebrand Karlén, L. Wahlberg · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

A LEGAL REVIEW OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURAL LAW REGARDING THE COMPLEXITY OF PROVING THE ELEMENT OF ECOLOGICAL LOSS IN COURT PROCEEDINGS

Environmental protection and management constitute an essential pillar for ensuring the human right to a good and healthy environment. In practice, environmental criminal law enforcement frequently encounters evidentiary obstacles at trial because ecological loss is technical, cumulative, and scientifically complex. Th...

Habibul Rakhman · 1 citation
Open access Nov 2026

HOSPITAL LIABILITY AND THE RIGHTS OF BPJS KESEHATAN PATIENTS AS CONSUMERS IN INDONESIA UNDER THE PRINCIPLE OF JUSTICE

This article examines hospitals’ legal responsibility for protecting the rights of patients enrolled in Indonesia’s National Health Insurance programme, administered by BPJS Kesehatan. It evaluates how far these patients’ rights as consumers of healthcare services are realised in practice and proposes a framework for h...

Roselyn Hutagaol, Dhaniswara K. Harjono, H. Panjaitan et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.