Evaluating or Ranking? Student Evaluation of Teaching in Higher Education and Strategies for Change
Abstract
Student Evaluation of Teaching (SET) plays a crucial role in the quality of teaching management and talent cultivation in universities. In order to see how SET is being carried out in China and its consequences, we conducted a study across eight top universities in China by interviews with faculties and students. It is found that shortcomings of SET practices include confusion between evaluation and ranking, lack of reliable inferences, incompatibility of questionnaire methods, inability to quantify complex definitions of excellent teaching, low satisfaction, and unsatisfactory outcomes. A developmental approach to SET should be implemented with such strategies as promoting mid-term feedback, designing flexible evaluation tools, diversifying assessment instruments, creating long-term open-ended feedback systems, and enhancing the professional competencies of evaluation personnel. By implementing these measures, SET can better fulfil its purpose as a tool for continuous improvement in teaching quality and student learning outcomes.