Skip to content
Open access

Evaluating the impact of water acidification on deposit formation on the membrane during reverse osmosis desalination [in Ukrainian]

Sep 2026 · Proceedings of the NTUU "Igor Sikorsky KPI". Series: Chemical engineering, ecology and resource saving · 0 citations · 13 references

Abstract

Providing environmentally safe drinking water and treating wastewater relies heavily on efficient desalination methods. Among these, low-pressure reverse osmosis (RO) is highly promising for residential and industrial water conditioning. However, a significant operational challenge remains scaling – the deposition of mineral precipitates on the membrane surface, which reduces membrane lifespan and efficiency. The primary aim of this research is to evaluate the performance of low-pressure RO membranes, specifically the Filmtec TW30-1812-75 model, during the desalination of municipal tap water. The study focuses on assessing the intensity of sediment deposition depending on the permeate recovery rate and the influence of water acidification on mitigating these deposits. The experimental study utilized a custom-designed laboratory reverse osmosis filtration unit operating at a constant pressure of 6.1 atm with a membrane specific flux of 0.0289 m/h. Tap water, characterized by an initial total hardness of 3.8-4.9 meq/dm3 and an alkalinity of 3.7-4.3 meq/dm3, was subjected to filtration. The permeate recovery rate was systematically varied from 40% up to 90%. To investigate the anti-scaling effect of pH adjustment, the feed water was acidified using hydrochloric acid (HCl) at doses of 1.25 meq/dm3 and 2.5 meq/dm3. Key physicochemical parameters, including total hardness, calcium and magnesium concentrations, total alkalinity, electrical conductivity, and pH, were rigorously monitored in both the permeate and the concentrate. To quantify the extent of scaling on the membrane surface, a mass balance approach was employed, comparing the theoretically calculated ion concentrations in the concentrate with the analytically measured values. The findings indicate that without pre-acidification, the low-pressure RO membrane exhibits excellent desalination efficiency, reducing the permeate hardness to 0.022-0.060 meq/dm3, which corresponds to a high selectivity of 98.75-99.45%. The residual alkalinity of the permeate decreased to 0.29-0.36 meq/dm3 (selectivity 91.43-93.1%). However, mass balance calculations revealed that scaling phenomena-primarily calcium carbonate precipitation-intensify substantially when the permeate recovery rate exceeds 65%. At a 90% recovery rate, the discrepancy between the theoretical and measured hardness in the concentrate reached 28.82 meq/dm3, confirming massive sediment deposition. The introduction of hydrochloric acid effectively lowered the initial alkalinity of the feed water, aiming to suppress carbonate scaling. With an HCl dose of 1.25 meq/dm3, the selectivity for hardness ions slightly decreased to 97.76-98.77%, and scaling was only partially mitigated. Increasing the HCl dose to 2.5 meq/dm3 reduced the feed water alkalinity to approximately 1.2 meq/dm3. While this aggressive acidification significantly inhibited calcium carbonate formation at moderate recovery rates, it did not completely resolve the scaling issue at the extreme recovery rate of 90%. At this threshold, the discrepancy in hardness still reached 14.84 meq/dm3. Due to the significant decrease in bicarbonate concentration and pH, there is a low probability of hardness ion precipitation using carbonates; therefore, the precipitation of other sparingly soluble salts, such as calcium sulfate (gypsum), likely occurred due to high concentration polarization. The practical significance of this work lies in defining the operational limits for low-pressure RO systems. It was established that operating below a 65% permeate recovery rate is critical to preventing severe scaling during standard tap water desalination. Acidification proves to be a viable method for increasing the recovery threshold by lowering alkalinity; however, it has limitations at very high recovery ratios due to the shifting solubility limits of non-carbonate scaling agents. Future investigations should focus on comparing the efficacy of polyphosphate, phosphonate, and sulfonate antiscalants to further optimize the stabilization of feed water in low-pressure RO applications.

Read PDF

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.