Skip to content
Review

The institutional trap of public enterprises in Russia: barriers, conflicts and stagnation

Sep 2026 · Economic problems and legal practice · Vol 22, pp. 227-237 · 0 citations · 2 references

Abstract

The article examines the institutional, legal, and managerial barriers to the development of employee-owned joint-stock companies (people's enterprises) in Russia. Drawing on sources that include survey data from workers at one such enterprise, court rulings, and financial reports, the authors demonstrate that formally granting workers shares without mechanisms for genuine participation in governance does not create a class of effective owners, but instead entrenches managerial power. The study identifies the key constraints embedded in Federal Law No. 115-FZ: the prohibition on establishing people's enterprises from scratch, the 75% threshold for employee share ownership, the 5% cap on any single shareholder, the "one shareholder — one vote" rule, and the compulsory buyback of shares upon dismissal. The paper concludes that the sector of people's enterprises is caught in an institutional trap, with legal restrictions perpetuating its current marginal position and preventing the realisation of the stated goals of ownership democratisation.

View source

Similar papers

Open access 2026

The state as shareholder and tax authority: Effects of state ownership on corporate tax avoidance

ABSTRACT This study aims to analyze the relationship between state ownership (SO) and the tax avoidance practices of firms listed on the Brazilian capital market. The research addresses two gaps in the literature. The first concerns the absence of metrics able to capture the State's proportional influence within firms'...

Leandro Josuel da Costa Santos, Héllen Karyne Duarte de Farias, Robério Dantas de França · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Control-Enhanced Mechanisms in Spain: Non-Voting Shares, Loyalty Shares, and the Implementation of the Directive on Multiple Voting Rights

This article analyzes the legal framework governing control-enhanced mechanisms under the Spanish Companies Act (Ley de Sociedades de Capital [LSC]) and examines the practical experience of Spanish public companies. As a general rule, the governing principle is proportionality, meaning that the law presumes a correlati...

Isabel Fernández Torres · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

QUALIFIED TRANSPARENCY IN MIXED ECONOMY COMPANIES: THE COMPATIBILITY BETWEEN THE LAI, THE STATE-OWNED ENTERPRISES STATUTE, AND EVALUATION SYSTEMS

Public transparency constitutes an essential instrument of social control and integrity of the Public Administration. Its application to state-owned enterprises, however, presents particularities due to the hybrid legal regime of these entities, which are subject to duties of publicity and governance, but may also oper...

Myllena Lima Falcão · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Mixed-economy companies in the United Arab Emirates

This study examines the legal nature and characterization of mixed-economy companies in the United Arab Emirates (UAE). While these entities have a commercial form under private law, their primary objective is to manage economic public utilities in the public interest. Utilizing a descriptive-analytical method, the res...

A. Alzaabi · 0 citations
Open access 2026

Economic Prosperity through a Balanced Formalism Approach in Public Joint-Stock Companies

In this article, we seek to address these fundamental questions: Does excessive formalism in commercial law, particularly within public joint-stock companies, hinder economic prosperity and public participation? And how can a prudent balance be established between structural requirements and the freedom of individual w...

Mohsen Esmaeili, Bakhtiar Abbaslou, Esmaeil Abbasi · 0 citations
Review Open access Oct 2026

Review of the efficacy of the Companies Act 71 of 2008 in regulating employee share-ownership schemes to achieve socio-economic development

The black majority in South Africa endured social and economic hardship under apartheid. Millions still lack everyday access to essential resources as a result of apartheid policies, even though the government has introduced legislative and institutional frameworks to alleviate poverty and inequality. This article cons...

Marvin R. Awarab · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.