Effects of biochars derived from different raw materials on Zn and Cd bioavailability and soil enzyme activities in Zn-Cd co-contaminated soil
Abstract
Biochar is widely used for heavy metal immobilization in co-contaminated soil, yet the remediation performance varies greatly with feedstock. This study aimed to evaluate the efficiency of four biochars derived from apple wood (A-BC), peanut shell (P-BC), corn straw (C-BC), and wheat straw (W-BC) on Zn and Cd availability, soil enzyme activity, and Zn and Cd accumulation in Brassica chinensis L. A pot experiment was conducted to investigate soil Zn and Cd fractions, metal uptake by Brassica chinensis L., and soil catalase, urease, and sucrase activities under biochar amendments. Two-way ANOVA and correlation analysis were applied to assess the effects of biochar type, application rate, and their interaction. C-BC and W-BC had ash contents nearly three-fold higher than A-BC and P-BC; all biochars were alkaline, with comparable pH values for A-BC and P-BC. The 5% biochar addition significantly decreased water-extractable (WA) Zn (20%-50%) and Cd (15%-35%), while residual Zn and Cd increased by 30%-90% and 110%-330%, respectively ( P < 0.05). Biochar type, application amount, and their interaction exerted extremely significant influences on soil extractable and residual Zn/Cd contents ( P < 0.001). W-BC exhibited the best Zn immobilization, reducing weak acid-extractable Zn by up to 47.8% and increasing residual Zn by up to 91.8% at the 5% application rate. P-BC was optimal for Cd stabilization and significantly increased residual Cd at all application rates (by up to 121%). Biochar type, rate, and their interaction significantly affected plant Zn and Cd uptake ( P < 0.0001). A-BC and C-BC most effectively reduced Zn and Cd accumulation in Brassica chinensis L. and lowered the corresponding dietary health risks of these two metals. Biochar amendment increased catalase, urease, and sucrase activities in a dose-dependent manner, with growth rates of 24%-38%, 17%-29%, and 22%-41%, respectively. Biochar type, rate, and their interaction significantly altered sucrase activity. Correlation analysis showed that changes in weak acid-extractable metal concentrations explained over 50% of the variance in plant metal accumulation and soil enzyme activity. Feedstock source determines the remediation performance of biochar in Zn-Cd co-contaminated soil. Biochar can immobilize soil Zn and Cd, reduce plant metal uptake and associated health risks, and restore soil enzyme functions. These findings provide practical guidance for selecting suitable biochar materials to remediate Zn-Cd co-contaminated farmland while preserving soil biochemical functions.