Skip to content
Open access

Comparative Evaluation of Direct and Recursive Multi-Step Forecasting for Electricity Demand Using Deep Learning and Gradient Boosting Models

Jul 2026 · Energies · 0 citations · 21 references

TL;DR

This study compares two multi-step forecasting strategies for 24-h horizons: a direct 24→24 strategy and a recursive strategy based on sequential 24→1 predictions, and concludes that the selection of a forecasting strategy depends on the required balance between overall accuracy, temporal stability, and computational cost.

Abstract

Predicting electrical demand in distribution systems is a fundamental problem for the efficient operation of smart grids, especially under scenarios of high temporal variability. This study compares two multi-step forecasting strategies for 24-h horizons: a direct 24→24 strategy and a recursive strategy based on sequential 24→1 predictions. Four machine learning and deep learning architectures are evaluated: LSTM, N-HiTS, U-Net, and LightGBM, using real data from electrical feeders belonging to distribution systems in the equatorial region of Ecuador. The methodology includes constructing time windows, non-overlapping train/validation/test partitioning for evaluation, consistent normalization, and comparative analysis using MAE, RMSE, and MAPE metrics. The results show that the direct 24→24 strategy achieves the best overall performance, with LSTM standing out with an approximate MAPE of 4.12%. However, the recursive strategies exhibit greater stability in the face of atypical patterns observed during holidays and weekends. Furthermore, U-Net demonstrates competitive performance in both accuracy and temporal robustness, while LightGBM stands out for its computational efficiency. It is concluded that the selection of a forecasting strategy depends on the required balance between overall accuracy, temporal stability, and computational cost.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Conference Jul 2026

LSTM–GRU Hybrid Deep Learning Model for Short-Term Load Forecasting in Smart Grid Systems

For smart grid power system planning and operation, short-term load forecasting is crucial. Important decisions including determining system safety, scheduling fuel, economically dispatching electricity, and selling energy can be aided by accurate day-ahead estimates. However, due to its reliance on external variables like weather, the process is intricate and computationally intensive. In order to address this issue, the paper proposes an LSTGR-based architecture that systematically enhances STLF in Smart Grids. The input characteristics are first scaled correctly using data normalisation. A hybrid feature selection method combining XGB and RF is utilised to determine the most essential features. Afterwards, RFE is employed to eliminate superfluous attributes. To facilitate learning, a hybrid deep learning model is trained using the updated dataset. This model combines LSTM and GRU. Using assessment criteria such as MAPE, MAE, MSE, and RMSE, the results demonstrate that the LSTGR model outperforms other models. With an RMSE of only 1.8%, the model clearly excels at producing accurate predictions. All things considered, the model successfully improves the reliability of forecasts while being computationally efficient. Because of this, it is an excellent option for smart grid applications in the actual world.

L. Jayavani, Banoth Ashwini, Kolkur Swabhavika et al. · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Comparative Analysis of LSTM and Hybrid Attention-Based Architectures for Short-Term Electricity Consumption Forecasting: A Case Study in Togo

Overall, the study demonstrates that recurrent deep learning architectures provide reliable and operationally relevant solutions for electricity consumption forecasting in highly structured energy demand series.

Séna Apeke, Yao Bokovi, K. Gbafa et al. · 0 citations
Jul 2026

Impact of Advanced Optimization Methods on the Predictive Performance of Temporal Convolutional Networks for Load Forecasting

Accurate short-term load forecasting is important for running power systems efficiently and managing smart grids. In this study, we present an improved Temporal Convolutional Network (TCN) model and compare eight optimization algorithms: Adam, AdaBelief, RAdam, Ranger, AdamP, NovoGrad, Adan, and SAM. We used hourly electricity load data from Denmark to test each optimizer under the same settings and with three different random seeds to ensure a fair and reliable comparison. All optimizers showed strong predictive accuracy, with root mean square error (RMSE) values between 0.03 and 0.05. Adan and AdamP had the lowest errors and were the most stable. These results show that the choice of optimizer has a big impact on how well TCN models learn and generalize. Our framework offers a solid benchmark for building adaptive and reliable forecasting systems for future smart grids.

Hmeda Musbah, Abdussalam Mohamed, Hamed H. Aly · 0 citations
Review Open access Aug 2026

Application and Comparative Study of Time Series Analysis Algorithms in New Energy Forecasting

The intermittent and volatile characteristics of new energy generation, together with the increasing demand for stable power supply in intelligent industrial systems, make accurate forecasting a critical issue for grid dispatch and electromagnetic energy management. This study systematically reviews the technological evolution of time series analysis methods for wind and photovoltaic (PV) power forecasting and establishes a comparative framework covering classical statistical models, intelligent learning algorithms, and hybrid modeling strategies. Based on two years of operational data collected from an actual wind farm and PV station in East China, the forecasting performance of ARIMA, exponential smoothing, Support Vector Regression (SVR), Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) networks, and Transformer architectures is comprehensively evaluated, while hybrid approaches based on Empirical Mode Decomposition (EMD) are further investigated. The results demonstrate that model selection should jointly consider forecasting horizon, data characteristics, and computational constraints. Classical statistical methods remain robust under stable operating conditions but are less effective in capturing extreme fluctuations, whereas deep learning approaches exhibit superior capability in modeling long-range temporal dependencies despite reduced interpretability. Decomposition-based hybrid strategies achieve a more balanced performance across diverse scenarios and show enhanced robustness under extreme weather conditions. The study further proposes a structured model selection guideline by matching data characteristics with operational requirements, providing theoretical support for forecasting system design in renewable-energy-driven power networks and offering useful references for electromagnetic energy utilization and intelligent industrial applications.

M. S. Song, C. Yang, Z. Heng et al. · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

Short-term PV power forecasting under real-world data constraints: a benchmark study of neural networks with uncertainty quantification

This study provides an in-depth comparative analysis of four state-of-the-art neural architectures, confirming that high-fidelity point forecasts and rigorously quantified uncertainty can be achieved simultaneously, providing a clear path toward more dependable PV dispatch, reserve allocation, and market participation.

Saloni Dhingra, G. Gruosso, G. Storti Gajani · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.