Steven Lukes, sociologist of fate
Abstract
The polite line of questioning when confronted by a proper name is to ask “Who is …?” The polite line of questioning when confronted by a proper name of eminent description is to ask “What is …?” Steven Lukes is such an eminence. A wholly irreplicable career, deservedly celebrated, revisited here through The Diversity of Morals, a book which brings multiple lines of Lukes’ thought, spanning decades, together and possibly to culmination. So what is Lukes? A social theorist of the truest kind, a verifiably voracious and omnivorous reader, an incomparable compiler and organizer of arguments, a superlative curator of quotation! All are correct. Most accurately, however, Lukes is a tutor (a “Don”) in the Oxford tradition, and in The Diversity of Morals, this uniquely literate, metadisciplinary, supra-professor visits several iterations of moral diversity, from politicized points of fracture, to untranslatable words, to incompatible research specialities, exposing all of them to be gradients of the same lie. For Lukes, “the category of the moral” is the most adequate expression of an all-too-human, unifying power—power over fate—particularly the fate of having to live among those whom we despise, i.e., who seem to “come like fate.” The effort is a significant, self-contained tutorial, but can morals prove as interesting as unifiers as they are as dividers, as Lukes hopes? Perhaps, but only if it is hope, indeed, that morals enliven.