Tracking Total Precipitable Water Vapor: A Multi-Instrument Comparative Analysis
Abstract
Atmospheric water vapor is a major driver of Earth’s climate, yet despite its vital role in driving extreme weather and informing Numerical Weather Prediction (NWP) models, precise quantification of Precipitable Water Vapor (PWV) remains a challenge due to its high spatial and temporal variability. To provide an upgraded evaluation reflecting the most recent data and next-generation instrumentation, this study evaluates the accuracy, relative to radiosonde measurements, in calculating PWV values across six different instruments: Microwave Radiometer (MWR), NOAA-21, TROPOMI, Pandora spectrometer, AERONET sun-photometer, and GNSS/GPS against the bias-corrected Vaisala RS-92 and RS-41 radiosondes over Beltsville, Maryland, utilizing an updated 2024–2025 database. As a certified GRUAN site, HUBC adheres to strict international observation standards designed specifically to provide reference-quality data and comprehensive corrections for systematic errors. This rigorous framework justifies their application as the definitive ‘referent truth’ benchmark for remote sensing validation. RMSE and bias were the primary metrics used to assess relative accuracy. GPS measurements provided the highest level of relative accuracy, yielding the lowest RMSE (1.50 mm) and a near-unity linear fit (y = 0.98x). NOAA-21 and TROPOMI exhibit higher random noise when compared to ground-based instrumentation, yet both obtain high relative accuracy retrievals with negligible biases. AERONET and Pandora also showed strong performance with low RMSEs and R2 values of 0.986 and 0.988, respectively, while slightly underestimating PWV. In contrast, the Radiometer performed with the lowest relative accuracy, characterized by the highest RMSE (6.19 mm) and a significant negative bias (−5.55 mm). Although all instruments maintained high correlation coefficients (R2 ≥ 0.904), these results indicate that satellite and ground-based remote sensing provide reliable PWV retrievals, while GPS presents the most robust benchmark for high-accuracy PWV retrievals relative to radiosonde measurements. The findings also underscore the need for instrument-specific calibration constants to better align remote sensing retrievals with in situ observations.