Skip to content
Preprint

Task- and Session-Level Model Routing: A Common-Interface Hybrid Evaluation of Four Open-Source Routers Across Four Benchmarks

Jul 2026 · 0 citations · 20 references
Computer Science Mathematics

TL;DR

A common measurement protocol and hybrid evaluation of four router implementations across RouterBench, BFCL v4, tau2-bench, and WebArena shows that, under these configurations and controls, observed gains track selected-tier composition more closely than demonstrated task-specific targeting.

Abstract

Agentic systems increasingly delegate model selection to a router, yet open-source routers are usually evaluated with different tasks, candidate pools, and execution protocols, limiting direct comparison. We present a common measurement protocol and hybrid evaluation of four router implementations across RouterBench, BFCL v4, tau2-bench, and WebArena. We evaluate 290 frozen tasks against a locked matrix of 2,610 candidate outcomes. Three routers emit constant or near-constant tier assignments; only vLLM Semantic Router varies materially with prompt content, and it has the highest observed success rate on none of the four benchmarks. Always-Mid matches Aurelio exactly on three benchmarks and within 0.003 on the fourth. For vLLM, task-level superiority tests detect no task-specific advantage over a share-matched content-blind allocation; equivalence is established only on WebArena at the protocol-declared five-percentage-point margin. The results show that, under these configurations and controls, observed gains track selected-tier composition more closely than demonstrated task-specific targeting. Fixed-tier baselines and selected-tier distributions are therefore necessary controls in router evaluation; the findings are scoped to these configurations, candidate pool, and frozen benchmark samples, not to routing paradigms in general.

View source

Similar papers

Preprint Aug 2026

SCOPE-Router: Cost-Aware Open-Set VLM Routing for Execution-Oriented Tasks

CRM+RCCR, an architecture-agnostic cost-aware objective that encodes cost preference into continuous relevance targets through per-pair independent scoring, eliminating multi-positive dilution while regularizing queries with similar routing preferences to be closer in the routing space.

Tao Yu, Yifei Qu, Zhiqing Cui et al. · 0 citations
#natural language process... Preprint Sep 2026

Beyond Fluent Generation: A CPU Reliability Benchmark for MCP-Style Tool Calling in Sub-2B Small Language Models for Edge Deployment

Resource constrained single-board computers including Raspberry Pi, NVIDIA Jetson Nano, Arduino UNO Q, Orange Pi, and LattePanda motivate on-device small language model (SLM) agents that reduce cloud dependence, improve data locality, and tolerate intermittent connectivity. Model Context Protocol (MCP)-style tool invocation demands more than fluent generation: an agent must emit machine-readable JSON, select the correct tool, supply all required arguments, and avoid unintended actions. We establish a platform-agnostic CPU baseline by evaluating five open-weight models below two billion parameters Phi-1.5, Pythia-1.4B, TinyLlama-1.1B-Chat, Qwen2.5-0.5B, and Qwen2.5-1.5B on 100 prompts spanning weather retrieval, web search, calculation, email composition, and task creation, under greedy decoding and nucleus sampling. A recovery parser strips Markdown fences, extracts brace-delimited substrings, and scores parseability, tool-name correctness, argument completeness, and value agreement. Under this criterion, Qwen2.5-1.5B achieves 75% (greedy) and 79% (sampling); Qwen2.5-0.5B achieves 72% (greedy) but drops to 32% under sampling. Phi-1.5 scores 0%; Pythia and TinyLlama reach at most 7%. A strict post-hoc audit finds only 5 of 1,000 raw responses directly parseable as JSON, exposing near-total dependence on output recovery. A CPU resource probe shows Qwen2.5-1.5B requires 7,960 MiB and 30.782 s mean latency; Qwen2.5-0.5B uses 3,637 MiB and 10.627 s, revealing a reliability-resource trade-off for edge deployment. These results do not cover the named boards directly or a full MCP implementation. Safe deployment requires schema validation, constrained generation, least-privilege execution, and human escalation for consequential actions.

Abrar Shahriar Qurat-Ul-Ain Mastoi · 0 citations
Preprint Aug 2026

Scrouting: Cost-Aware Routing of Coding Agents by Scouting the Repository First

SuperScout is presented, which routes after scouting the repository: a 7B searcher, SuperScout-7B, first explores the repository and produces a structured handoff whose reproduction claims are sandbox-verified, with false claims stripped before delivery.

Ishaan Bhola, Adithya Krishnan, NS Mukunda · 0 citations
Open access Jul 2026

Contamination-Free LLM Routing on LiveBench Reasoning Tasks: Accuracy-Cost-Latency Tradeoff Learning

Fresh, objectively scored benchmark items can support auditable accuracy-cost-latency routing when features encode verifiable computational structure, and show that fresh, objectively scored benchmark items can support auditable accuracy-cost-latency routing when features encode verifiable computational structure.

Grace Xu · 0 citations
Preprint Aug 2026

LLM within MCP Matters: Measuring Inefficient Resource Utilization Driven by LLMs

The Model Context Protocol (MCP) standardizes how servers expose data and tools to Large Language Models (LLMs). A common server design embeds frequently used reference data, such as identifier lookup tables, directly in the server instructions: the system-prompt text a server hands to the host application. When a query concerns an entry of the embedded table, the model can act on it immediately instead of re-discovering the same information through a search tool. We test whether client LLMs actually consume such instruction-embedded data, reporting a 54,000-trial study across 24 LLMs (9 Claude, 6 Gemini, 9 GPT) on a production legal-information MCP server. A diagnostic condition that removes the competing search tool shows that failures are dominated by behavioral preference rather than missing capability. With search unavailable, 23 of 24 models read the embedded data reliably (hit ratio at least 98%); with a search tool merely present, 9 models drop below 15%. A 2^3 factorial analysis of three instruction-level interventions reveals strong interaction effects: combining all three restores at least 86% for 20 of 24 models, but individual interventions can backfire for specific model families. Per-server prompt engineering is therefore a workaround rather than a fix; we argue that MCP host applications should provide an explicit mechanism that places server instructions ahead of tool selection in the client LLM's deliberation.

Minhan Cho, Soyoung Park, Kihyeon Jeong et al. · 0 citations
Conference Jul 2026

UDP-Based Virtual Network Slicing Simulator with Resource Borrowing and Jain Fairness Evaluation

Network slicing is a key enabling technology for fifth-generation (5G) and beyond mobile networks, which enables operators to run multiple logical networks on top of common physical infrastructure while meeting heterogeneous quality-ofservice (QoS) requirements. In this paper, we summarize the design, implementation, and evaluation of a UDP-based virtual network slicing simulator modeling four slices in accordance with 3GPP service types: enhanced Mobile Broadband (eMBB), Ultra-Reliable Low-Latency Communications (URLLC), Massive Machine-Type Communications (mMTC), and a dedicated Best Effort slice. The simulator uses real UDP sockets on localhost in a multi-threaded framework and implements separate admission control per slice, supporting three configurable resourceborrowing modes—none, full, and controlled—in which the primary slices (eMBB, URLLC, mMTC) may borrow unused capacity from the Best Effort slice when their own allocation runs out. QoS metrics including throughput, packet loss ratio, one-way delay, and jitter are collected in a thread-safe manner per slice. Experimental results under controlled borrowing (60 s, 16 nodes, 3 MB per slice, 40% borrow cap) demonstrate activation of the borrowing mechanism with nonzero borrowed-in and borrowedout values, and illustrate the trade-off between primary-slice throughput and Best Effort protection.

Sroor Habeeb Mahmood, Ali Al-Allawee · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.