AI-Assisted Sustainability Intelligence and Decision Support in Manufacturing Organizations Using Expert-Validated Indicators Under the Triple Bottom Line Framework
The SIM Model is presented, an AI-assisted sustainability intelligence architecture for manufacturing organizations that comprises literature-based indicator synthesis, Fuzzy Delphi Technique, Pareto 80/20 screening, Group Analytic Hierarchy Process, Utility Value Analysis and the web-based AI-enabled decision support system (AI-DSS) under the Triple Bottom Line (TBL) framework.
Abstract
Industrial sustainability assessment needs a transparent and operational framework that can manage multidimensional indicators, expert uncertainty, weighting complexity, and managerial interpretation. This research presents the Sustainable Industrial Measurement (SIM) Model, an AI-assisted sustainability intelligence architecture for manufacturing organizations. The model comprises literature-based indicator synthesis, Fuzzy Delphi Technique (FDT), Pareto 80/20 screening, Group Analytic Hierarchy Process (Group AHP), Utility Value Analysis and the web-based AI-enabled decision support system (AI-DSS) under the Triple Bottom Line (TBL) framework. In FDT validation by consensus, threshold and fuzzy score criteria, 33 experts accepted 64 indicators. The Pareto screening reduced the set to 50 high-impact indicators, consisting of 10 economic, 22 social and 18 environmental indicators. The priority weights were derived from the group AHP weighting by 21 experts and checked for consistency. The environmental and economic indicators represent the dominant sustainability priorities. The weighted structure was embedded in the web-based AI-DSS to enable automated scoring, visualization, gap diagnosis and AI-based managerial recommendations. Thirty industrial practitioners reported excellent perceived usability of the SIM Model, with a System Usability Scale score of 86.0. However, the evaluation assessed usability only, not the accuracy, effectiveness, or organizational impact of AI-assisted recommendations for manufacturing sustainability decisions and future implementation.
This study addresses the underexplored financial side of smart tourism by validating an integrated ESG-AI-MCDM decision-support framework. The model links AI-driven predictive analytics with a hybrid multi-criteria loop combining AHP, TOPSIS, and DEA to evaluate strategic alternatives under seasonality and sustainability constraints. Quantitative validation via structural equation modelling (SEM) with 416 active participants proved that AI analytics significantly enhance managerial efficiency (
β
= 0.49) and operational resilience (
β
= 0.36). Empirically, the AI platform cut operational costs by 26% and boosted visitor satisfaction by 18%. When ESG criteria held a dominant 35% weight, hybrid optimisation identified sustainable energy investment as the optimal strategy, achieving a top TOPSIS score of 0.83 and a superior DEA efficiency score of 0.91. The framework eliminates subjective managerial bias, providing a scalable, resilient financial governance mechanism for tourism SMEs.
Judit Katalin Fejes, Etelka Katits· Journal of Smart Tourism· 0 citations
This study aims to propose an integrated framework for monitoring vaccine supply chain (VSC) sustainability across multiple regions by combining subjective expert judgement and objective performance data. It also examines how regional rankings change when the relative emphasis on these two evidence sources varies.
A VSC sustainability evaluation index was developed using sustainability criteria and associated performance indicators across economic, social and environmental dimensions. Subjective weights were derived using spherical fuzzy DEMATEL to capture causal interrelationships among criteria under uncertain expert judgement. Objective weights were obtained using CRITIC to identify criteria with high regional variation and non-redundant information. The two weights were combined through a sensitivity factor, and VIKOR was applied to generate compromise rankings of regions.
The framework was applied to 18 blocks in an Indian district. SF-DEMATEL identified cost optimisation, sustainable financing and training as the most structurally influential criteria. CRITIC identified sustainable financing, workforce requirement and energy and emission as the most informative criteria for differentiating regional performance. Under balanced weighting, Namkum and Sonahatu emerged as the strongest-performing blocks, while Chanho and Itki appeared among the weakest. Sensitivity analysis showed that some blocks remained stable across weighting conditions, whereas others were more sensitive to expert-derived causal judgement.
The framework helps public health managers identify whether a region requires expert-led systemic diagnosis, PI-level corrective action or broader multi-criteria strengthening.
This study develops a VSC sustainability assessment framework integrating causal expert weights, objective regional performance information and sensitivity-based ranking diagnosis.
Pratik Rai, Sasadhar Bera· Journal of Humanitarian Logi...· 0 citations
The purpose of this study is to identify and prioritize the sustainability indicators (SIs) perceived as most influential for project success within Iran’s volatile socioeconomic environment. It aims to bridge the gap between global sustainability standards and local operational realities in resource-constrained contexts.
A sequential mixed-methods design used a hybrid multicriteria decision-making framework. First, the fuzzy delphi method (FDM) screened indicators using an 11-expert panel. Second, the method based on the removal effects of criteria (MEREC) objectively weighted the success criteria based on data variance. Finally, the combined compromise solution (CoCoSo) method ranked the SIs.
The analysis reveals a context-specific prioritization where financial analysis, project safety and resilience emerged as the top-ranked indicators, while renewable materials ranked lowest. This suggests that in sanctioned, high-inflation settings, practitioners prioritize economic viability and operational risk mitigation; broader environmental aspirations are strategically deferred until foundational project continuation is secured.
The findings reflect expert judgments predominantly from heavy industrial sectors in Iran. Therefore, results are context-bound and may not fully capture the nuances of agile sectors (e.g. software) or translate to stable macroeconomic environments.
For practitioners in volatile markets, the study provides a resource allocation roadmap. It recommends integrating financial and safety metrics into core control systems (e.g. earned value management) and dynamic risk registers, moving beyond “one-size-fits-all” sustainability checklists.
This paper integrates the FDM-MEREC-CoCoSo framework into sustainable project management to minimize subjective bias. It contributes empirical evidence extending contingency theory by demonstrating that macroeconomic volatility fundamentally reorders sustainability priorities, reframing sustainability in volatile environments as a pragmatic risk-management strategy.
Mohammad Fallah, R. Tumpa· Journal of Engineering, Desi...· 0 citations
A multi-criteria decision-making framework for evaluating six AI tools against eight sustainability-oriented criteria indicates that improving individual productivity and enhancing employee engagement and motivation are the most influential evaluation criteria.
A. Puška, Jurica Bosna, Darko Božanić· Journal of Operations Intell...· 0 citations
This paper investigates the role of contemporary MCDM approaches in improving organizational performance assessment and strategic decision-making by examining methodological developments, practical implementation frameworks, evaluation indicators, and performance outcomes and proposes an integrated conceptual framework that facilitates objective strategic prioritization, efficient resource allocation, and sustainable organizational competitiveness.
Dr. Padmavathi SM¹, S² Dr.Suma, B. Dr.LakshmiR et al.· Journal of Intelligent Decis...· 0 citations