Skip to content
Review Open access

Decision support for sustainable household waste processing: a comparative evaluation of ahp and fuzzy ahp

Sep 2026 · International Journal of Industrial Optimization · pp. 122-131 · 0 citations · 30 references

Abstract

Urban household waste management in developing countries faces increasing complexity due to population growth, land constraints, and socio-environmental considerations. This study proposes a comparative evaluation of the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) and Fuzzy AHP to support decision-making in selecting sustainable household waste treatment alternatives in Umbulharjo Sub-district, Yogyakarta City, Indonesia. Five sustainability criteria and five alternative treatment methods were identified through expert consultation and literature review. Primary data were collected from 20 household respondents using structured questionnaires. The AHP method applied a crisp pairwise comparison scale, while Fuzzy AHP incorporated linguistic assessments converted into Triangular Fuzzy Numbers to better handle uncertainty and subjectivity. The results demonstrate that while AHP prioritizes the burning method due to perceived simplicity and feasibility, Fuzzy AHP reveals a stronger preference for “Sorting, Hoarding, and Selling,” reflecting the community’s implicit environmental and economic concerns. The divergence in outcomes highlights the limitations of deterministic assessments in complex socio-technical systems and underscores the added value of fuzzy logic in capturing nuanced stakeholder preferences. By integrating quantitative and qualitative criteria within a hierarchical decision framework, this study contributes to the development of more context-sensitive and adaptive decision-support tools. The findings offer practical guidance for municipal authorities and urban planners seeking to align waste management strategies with cleaner production principles. The proposed methodological framework enhances transparency, inclusiveness, and responsiveness in sustainability assessments, supporting the transition toward more resilient and community-driven urban waste systems.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access Sep 2026

A Socio-Technical Fuzzy Decision-Support Framework for Sustainable Smart Waste Management

The adoption of smart waste management systems (SWMSs) is increasingly important for textile organizations seeking to improve sustainability while addressing interconnected technological, managerial, organizational, and environmental constraints. A persistent gap is that prior SWMS studies often examine digital technol...

Fazeelat Aziz, A. Qazi · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Decision Support System for Waste Prioritization Using the Preference Selection Index (PSI) Method at the Binjai City Environmental Agency

Waste prioritization at the Binjai City Environmental Agency remains constrained by an assessment process that lacks a systematic, measurable approach capable of reducing subjectivity, although each waste type has different characteristics and risk levels. This study develops a Decision Support System using the Prefere...

B. Ginting, Magdalena Simanjuntak, Yusfrizal · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF AHP AND FUZZY LOGIC FOR CULTURAL LANDSCAPE-BASED EVALUATION OF LAND-USE ALTERNATIVES: A CASE STUDY OF THE KARTAL QUARRY AREA (ISTANBUL)

This study aims to evaluate alternative land-use classes for the defunct Kartal Quarry in Istanbul within the scope of landscape restoration using cultural landscape criteria. A multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) framework combining Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) and a fuzzy logic-based approach was employed, wi...

Beyza Çermikli, E. Tarakçı, Recep Duranay · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

Digital Transformation of Municipal Waste Management in African Cities: A Socio-Technical Framework for Smart Waste Collection

Rapid urbanisation and changing consumption patterns have intensified municipal solid waste-management challenges across African cities, where conventional collection is constrained by inadequate infrastructure, limited finance, irregular scheduling and weak information flows. Internet of Things (IoT) technologies offe...

Okoro Emeka Frank, I. Jibril, N. I. Medugu et al. · 0 citations
Review Oct 2026

An expert-based AHP decision framework for prioritizing greywater reuse integration criteria in sustainable urban development

This study develops a decision-support framework for integrating greywater reuse into sustainable urban environments using the Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP). The study prioritizes multi-scale criteria that influence greywater system implementation and translates them into a practical planning tool. A structured...

A. Selim, Nessma M. Ismail, H. Gaber · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.