Skip to content
Review Open access

Progress in Aesthetic Models: From Formal Regularities to Situated Multilevel Valuation

Sep 2026 · Critical Humanistic Social Theory · Vol 3 · 0 citations · 58 references

Abstract

Aesthetic models have expanded from accounts centered on formal order, prototypicality, complexity, and processing fluency to multilevel explanations involving predictive dynamics, affective valuation, self-related meaning, expertise, cultural context, and computational representation. This structured integrative review synthesizes foundational and recent evidence from empirical aesthetics, cognitive psychology, neuroaesthetics, and computational image assessment. The evidence shows that no single tradition supersedes the others: formal variables constrain perception; recurrent cognitive operations transform perception into appraisal; distributed neural systems support sensation, valuation, emotion, memory, and meaning; and context and individual differences determine which criteria are applied. Computational models have improved large-scale prediction, distributional scoring, and personalization, but predictive performance alone does not identify psychological mechanisms. To connect these levels, the review proposes a Situated Multilevel Aesthetic Model comprising object representation, predictive processing, affective valuation, self-meaning integration, and social-institutional context. The model treats aesthetic outcomes and their uncertainty as time-dependent functions of stimulus, viewer, and situation. Methodological priorities include construct-specific outcomes, factorial context manipulation, time-resolved measurement, multilevel and cross-cultural sampling, preservation of disagreement in datasets, and intervention-based validation of explanations. The resulting framework positions aesthetic modeling as an evidence-integrated enterprise in which psychological theory defines constructs, neuroscience constrains process, computation tests generalization, and humanistic inquiry identifies the institutional conditions of value.

Read PDF

Similar papers

Open access Sep 2026

Toward a Neuro-Yijing Model: Musical Imagery, Affect, and Reflective Experience in Chinese Programmatic Music

Neuroaesthetic research has often examined aesthetic experience through measurable categories such as beauty, pleasure, preference, prediction, and reward. Although these approaches have produced important insights, they do not fully explain how culturally situated musical experience may be organized around sound-induc...

Ding-Yuan Zhang · 0 citations
Open access Oct 2026

Socially embedded predictive construction: a model of emotional experience

The dominant view in affective neuroscience has long held that discrete emotional states are universal, biologically fixed, and implemented in dedicated neural circuits. This ‘basic emotions’ framework faces accumulating challenges from neuroimaging meta-analyses, cross-cultural research, and studies of individual vari...

Raffaele Grimaldi · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

The Neural Architecture of Aesthetic Cognition: A Predictive-Processing Essay in Support of the TransformativeArts Framework

The TransformativeArts Framework (TAF) holds that the neural systems recruited to make and perceive art are not peripheral modules but expressions of the core architecture of thought. This essay asks whether contemporary neuroscience supports that claim, and it identifies three observations that the predictive-processi...

Scott Thomas Carter · 0 citations
Review Sep 2026

Valuation as a bridge between aesthetics and creativity.

Evidence shows that aesthetic evaluations are underpinned by mechanisms in the reward system that compute value for objects of interest. In turn, recent behavioral, computational, and neuroimaging evidence suggests that creativity involves a similar valuation process, as people generate and evaluate the originality and...

O. Vartanian, M. Skov, M. Nadal et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access Oct 2026

Emotion Beyond Bias: Affective and Cultural Scaffolding in Self-Regulation and Metacognition

Intelligent performance depends on how cognitive ability is deployed, and its deployment is regulated by metacognitive and affective processes. This theoretical article concerns regulated deployment, on which the gap between maximal and typical performance depends, and leaves the structure of ability outside its scope....

A. Conti, A. Bortolotti, A. Crociata et al. · 0 citations
#artificial intelligence Preprint Oct 2026

Cognition-Oriented Emotion Tracing from Causes to Consequences in Real-World Social Scenes

Affective computing has progressed from categorical emotion recognition to open-ended affective analysis with large multimodal models. Yet affective science describes emotion as an unfolding process shaped by appraisal, regulation, and social interpretation, which remains underexplored computationally. We propose TRACE...

Hao Li, Jin-Ye Zhang, Bobo Li et al. · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.