Skip to content
Open access

The Psychology of Corruption Across Cultures

Abstract

Corruption is not merely an institutional failure, it is fundamentally a psychological and cultural phenomenon, rooted in how individuals morally reason, disengage, and behave in social environments. This dissertation examines the psychological and cultural processes underlying moral judgment and corrupt behaviour across cultures, with a primary comparative focus on Indonesia and the Netherlands: two societies bound by a colonial history yet standing at opposite ends of the global corruption spectrum. Guided by the Moral Stages Model of Corrupt Behaviour, which maps the sequential processes of moral awareness, moral emotions, moral judgment, and moral self-identification culminating in moral behaviour, this dissertation tests a central theoretical question: does corruption prevalence shape how citizens morally judge and engage in corruption? Two opposing hypotheses are examined. First, the Descriptive Norms Hypothesis, predicting that citizens in high-corruption societies become more morally lenient, and second, the Relative Deprivation Hypothesis, predicting the opposite: that citizens who live with corruption's daily consequences condemn it more harshly. Across three empirical chapters, findings consistently support the Relative Deprivation Hypothesis. Chapter 2, comparing Indonesia and the Netherlands, demonstrated that Indonesian participants condemned corruption more severely, demanded harsher punishment, and expressed greater contempt toward corruptors than Dutch participants. A migration study further revealed that Indonesian students who relocated to the Netherlands shifted toward more lenient attitudes, indicating that moral judgments are dynamic and environmentally shaped. Chapter 3 extended these findings to eight countries: the Netherlands, UK, France, Greece, Malaysia, India, Indonesia, and Pakistan. It aimed to uncover a Divergence Effect: in high-corruption countries, perceived corruption intensified moral condemnation through relative deprivation and anger; in low-corruption countries, it paradoxically produced greater leniency, consistent with moral licensing and system justification. Indonesian participants exhibited the strongest condemnation and anger across all countries. Chapter 4 shifted focus to collaborative corrupt behaviour using a dyadic dice-roll paradigm. Direct communication consistently increased collaborative cheating across both Indonesian and international samples. CCTV surveillance deterred cheating only among Indonesian participants, suggesting that the deterrent effect of public monitoring is culturally contingent, likely tied to shame-proneness in collectivist societies. The dissertation concludes that morality is profoundly context-dependent. Effective anti-corruption strategies must be culturally tailored, meaning by leveraging moral emotions and narratives of shared injustice in high-corruption contexts, while countering complacency and moral licensing in low-corruption ones.

Read PDF

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.