A reuse paradox is revealed: although skills are intended to be easily imported and reused, developers spend a lot of effort rewriting what the skills do, fixing skill discoverability, and translating them for different tools and languages, indicating a need for better abstractions, standardized interfaces, and automated support for skill adaptation.
Abstract
As Large Language Model (LLM) agents become integral to modern software systems, ``skills''have emerged as a novel unit of software reuse, enabling developers to package workflows, decision procedures, and prompt-based policies. While skills are intended for reuse, downstream developers frequently modify published skills to fit local contexts, yet little is known about the nature of such adaptations. This paper presents the first empirical study of downstream skill adaptation in public forks, to understand how published skills are adapted, and to provide implications for researchers and engineers on improving skill design, evolution, and orchestration. Specifically, we analyze 1,126 skill-adaptation instances from six widely adopted skill repositories and develop a taxonomy comprising 46 adaptation patterns organized into 13 families. Our key findings reveal a reuse paradox: although skills are intended to be easily imported and reused, developers spend a lot of effort rewriting what the skills do, fixing skill discoverability, and translating them for different tools and languages, indicating a need for better abstractions, standardized interfaces, and automated support for skill adaptation. Furthermore, adaptations are highly interdependent, with changes in one component often requiring coordinated updates elsewhere, motivating automated support for detecting inconsistent modifications. We also find that nearly one-fifth of adaptations introduce security-sensitive content within the same instruction text that governs behavior.
Software engineering (abbrev. SE) has continuously evolved through increasingly powerful forms of reuse, from source code and libraries to components and services. Recent advances in AI agents have introduced a potentially new reusable artifact: skills. Emerging agent skill repositories and marketplaces enable developers to package, share, and reuse SE expertise as reusable skills. This trend raises a fundamental question: what SE activities are being encapsulated into reusable skills? Existing studies primarily focus on a broad range of skills acquisition, safety, or benchmarking, while lacking a systematic understanding of SE-specific skills and their coverage across the software development lifecycle. To address this gap, we conduct the first large-scale empirical study of SE skills in public repositories and marketplaces. We collect and analyze a large corpus of SE skills, examining the activities they encapsulate, lifecycle coverage, evolution characteristics, and evaluation mechanisms. Our findings reveal that SE activities are increasingly becoming reusable artifacts via skills and suggest promising research opportunities for skill recommendation and engineering-oriented structuring, as well as the need for mechanisms to encapsulate high-context SE activities into reusable skills. Overall, our study provides the first activity-centric characterization of SE skills and reveals how SE activities are increasingly being transformed into reusable skills. These findings offer new insights into skill reuse, ecosystem development, and the future of agent-centric SE.
Jialun Cao, Xinru Yan, Songqiang Chen et al.· 0 citations
This work proposes a framework for extracting reusable developer preferences from interaction traces, generates personalized skills through rule-based bootstrapping and evidence-grounded refinement, and evaluates them using a reproducible replay framework with an interactive, trajectory-conditioned LLM-based human developer simulator.
Shuyan Huang, Kai Du, Andrew S. Lan· 3 citations· ⚡2
A taxonomy-driven survey asks how dynamic skill libraries change over time in large language model agents, and synthesizes dynamic skill systems as lifecycle-managed, verified, evolving artifact stores.
This note argues that a skill is a software artefact and that its construction should follow software-engineering principles, with qualifications: single responsibility, separation of interface from implementation, low coupling, and economy in a shared token budget, together with behavioural evaluation in place of deterministic testing.
This paper examines how skills may help address bottlenecks of current agents and how they may expand agent capabilities through reusable domain procedures loaded at inference time and outlines open questions in skill construction, composition, evaluation, portability, governance, and security.
Hanwen Xing, Haomin Zhuang, Xuandong Zhao et al.· Proceedings of the 32nd ACM...· 7 citations· ⚡1
AI agents are becoming a fundamental part of modern software creation, helping developers in generating code, debugging, designing systems, etc. But there is a clear difference between how beginners and experienced software engineers get benefits from these tools. Newbies usually depend on agents for one-time prompts and quick answers, whereas mature users utilize them through well-defined, repeated workflows that raise productivity and consistency. In this article, we discuss this difference and emphasize that getting the full potential does not merely depend on better prompts but on workflows driven by instructions developers create clear and reusable instruction files to direct agent behavior across tasks. When developers stop seeing agents only as chat interfaces but as programmable collaborators, they can produce more reliable and high-quality outputs. We offer in our paper methods like designing modular instructions, narrowing down the context, and iterative refinement loops, as well as a case study illustrating how a team made a code review more efficient and minimized the rework by making agent instructions standard. The results stress that structured forms of interaction rather than sporadic use are the main ways to tap into advanced features. Our paper provides a conceptual model for agent usage at large scale, hands-on advice for the implementation of instruction files in actual settings, and validation that skillful developers can far exceed basic usage by adopting orderly, system-like approaches to agent collaboration.
Madhurima Kommuru, Srujana Pulipaka· International Journal of Mod...· 0 citations
We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads.
See our Cookie Policy.
