Skip to content
Open access

Stress or arousal? Exercise confounding in wearable stress detection

Sep 2026 · Medical Engineering and Physics · Vol 147 · 0 citations · 25 references
Physics Medicine

Abstract

Wearable stress-detection models are commonly validated by separating rest from stress, but this does not establish that their outputs are specific to stress rather than broader physiological activation. We re-analysed two public wearable datasets and made a matched within-dataset stress-specificity experiment the primary test. PhysioNet event tags were used to reconstruct protocol-defined rest and stress-induction blocks; 29 participants with matched aerobic and anaerobic recordings contributed 522 rest, 192 stress, and 3431 exercise-session windows. Four feature-based classifiers were trained to distinguish rest from stress under nested leave-one-participant-out evaluation. Preprocessing, hyperparameter selection, and probability-threshold calibration used training participants only, and exercise-session data were excluded from all model development. The best calibrated model, XGBoost, achieved balanced accuracy of 0.703, stress detection of 0.604, and rest specificity of 0.801, yet labelled 82.6% of held-out exercise-session windows as stress. At participant level, its exercise-session false-stress rate was 0.840 [0.775, 0.897], compared with a rest false-stress rate of 0.221 [0.151, 0.301], giving a paired difference of 0.619 [0.537, 0.699]. Protocol-defined stress blocks also had higher self-reported stress than rest blocks (mean difference 1.22 [0.89, 1.53] on the supplied 1–10 scale; 27/29 participants; one-sided Wilcoxon p=4.64×10−6). Adding time-domain heart-rate-variability features did not materially change the result. A wearable stress and affect detection-to-PhysioNet transfer analysis remained poor but was treated as secondary evidence because it also contains dataset and protocol shift. These findings show that exercise-associated activation can produce substantial false-stress responses even when stress recognition and an exercise-session challenge are evaluated within the same dataset and the challenge data are excluded from model development.

Read PDF

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.