Deep Learning Versus LASSO-Based Machine Learning for 1-Year Survival After Surgery for Spinal Metastases: A JASA Multicenter Prospective Cohort Analysis.
The 50-variable DL model provided reasonable prediction and generated clinically plausible feature-importance hypotheses, but it did not demonstrate a clearly meaningful performance advantage over the simpler 5-variable LASSO-based ML model.
To evaluate predictors associated with 1-year survival after surgery for spinal metastases by comparing a comprehensive 50-variable deep learning (DL) model with a previously published 5-variable LASSO-based machine learning (ML) model and applying DL-based permutation feature importance as an exploratory analytic lens.
SUMMARY OF
Background
DATA
Surgical decision-making for spinal metastases requires reliable survival estimates. Traditional scores such as those of Tokuhashi and Tomita and contemporary tools such as SORG and NESMS support prognostication, but performance and calibration may vary across cohorts. A parsimonious 5-variable JASA ML model is clinically practical, whereas DL may help identify prognostic signals embedded in detailed activities of daily living (ADLs), patient-reported outcomes (PROs), and scoring-system components.
Methods
We analyzed 401 complete-case patients who underwent surgery for spinal metastases at 35 Japanese institutions (2018-2021). A feed-forward neural network incorporating 50 preoperative variables was evaluated using five repeated random 8:2 train-test splits. Accuracy, AUROC, Brier score, and calibration summaries were reported and descriptively compared with the previously published 5-variable LASSO-based ML model.
Results
At 1 year, 269 of 401 patients were alive. The DL model achieved 75.5+/- 3.0% accuracy (95% confidence interval [CI], 71.8%-79.2%), held-out AUROC 0.789 (95% CI, 0.681-0.886), and Brier score 0.214. The ML model achieved 71.8% accuracy (Wilson 95% CI, 67.2%-76.0%) and apparent AUROC 0.762. Because the comparison was descriptive rather than paired, formal statistical superiority was not claimed. DL feature importance highlighted Vitality Index-On and Off Toilet, EQ-5D-5L total score and pain/discomfort, and individual Tokuhashi/Tomita components; the ML-selected Vitality Index-Wake Up item ranked 38th.
Conclusions
The 50-variable DL model provided reasonable prediction and generated clinically plausible feature-importance hypotheses, but it did not demonstrate a clearly meaningful performance advantage over the simpler 5-variable ML model. DL may be most useful for research-based feature discovery and refinement of future parsimonious prognostic tools, whereas validated simple models remain more practical for bedside prognostication.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE
2.
Background: Prognostic models for metastatic spinal tumors have evolved from conventional point-based scores to models incorporating treatment, laboratory, and machine-learning variables. However, comparisons in contemporary Japanese surgical cohorts remain limited. Methods: This retrospective study included 171 of 208...
J. Miyahara, Kazuki Abe, Rie Kodama et al.· Journal of Clinical Medicine· 0 citations
Brain metastases (BM) from renal cell carcinoma (RCC) significantly affect survival, and disease-specific prognostic tools for patients undergoing stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) remain limited. We aimed to identify prognostic factors and develop an interpretable machine learning (ML) model for individualized ris...
S. Ozgul, Melis Parabas, Peng Li et al.· Neuro-Oncology Practice· 0 citations
Background Lung adenocarcinoma is the most common subtype of non-small cell lung cancer and a leading cause of cancer-related mortality worldwide. Its marked clinical heterogeneity results in variable outcomes and poor prognosis for many patients. This study aimed to develop and compare statistical, machine learning, a...
J. H. Gil-Gómez, C. Carvajal-Fierro, Ricardo Bruges-Maya et al.· Frontiers in Oncology· 0 citations
Using structured preoperative clinical data, machine-and deep-learning models to predict overall survival in patients with CRLM are developed and compared to well established Basingstoke Predictive Index.
Nikhil Pramod Kumar, S. Drejian, M. Akhavi et al.· Frontiers in Oncology· 0 citations
An explainable deep learning model was developed and evaluated, which predicted survival during the first year after radiotherapy with discrimination and calibration comparable to those of a Cox proportional hazards model, indicating that this prognostic information can be provided as a simple bedside score rather than...
Yui Watanabe, T. Tomoda, A. Iwata et al.· Current Oncology· 0 citations
We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads.
See our Cookie Policy.