Sep 2026· Journal of Global Social Transformation· 0 citations· 30 references
TL;DR
A dual and often paradoxical relationship between AI integration and student development is revealed, examining the multifaceted ways in which AI-mediated learning environments influence learners' capacity for self-direction, independent decision-making, and the formation of their academic and personal identities.
Abstract
The rapid proliferation of artificial intelligence (AI) tools in educational settings has catalyzed significant scholarly interest in how these technologies reshape two fundamental dimensions of learner development: student autonomy and student identity. This narrative literature review synthesizes evidence from 30 peer-reviewed and scholarly works published predominantly between 2024 and 2026, examining the multifaceted ways in which AI-mediated learning environments influence learners' capacity for self-direction, independent decision-making, and the formation of their academic and personal identities. Drawing on studies conducted across diverse educational contexts (including higher education, secondary schooling, language learning, and creative disciplines), the review reveals a dual and often paradoxical relationship between AI integration and student development. On one hand, AI tools such as adaptive learning platforms, AI-powered feedback systems, and generative models like ChatGPT have been found to enhance student autonomy by offering personalized learning pathways, immediate feedback, and opportunities for self-regulated exploration. On the other hand, critical concerns have emerged regarding learner over-reliance, diminished critical thinking, erosion of epistemic agency, and the destabilization of learner identity when students navigate AI-assisted environments. The review further identifies tensions between productivity gains and identity coherence, and highlights the mediating roles of AI literacy, self-efficacy, and institutional context. Implications for educators, curriculum designers, and policymakers are discussed, alongside recommendations for balanced and ethically informed AI integration in education.
The increasing use of artificial intelligence (AI) in secondary education has created new opportunities for personalized support, immediate feedback, problem-solving, and self-directed learning, while also raising concerns about students’ reliance on AI-generated information. This narrative literature review examined A...
John Rey C. Tumulin· International Journal of Sus...· 0 citations
Artificial intelligence (AI) has rapidly evolved from a peripheral instructional aid into a central force reshaping how teaching and learning are designed, delivered, and evaluated. This article presents a narrative literature review of twenty-five studies published between 2021 and 2026 to map the opportunities, chall...
Andrian Sah, Muhammad Arsyad· Archipel· 0 citations
This study systematically synthesizes recent literature on AI-based learning and proposes an integrated conceptual framework showing that AI literacy and technological readiness strengthen psychological factors, which enhance student engagement, promote self-regulated learning, and ultimately contribute to academic ach...
Saefulah Saefulah, M. Lapasau, W. Widodo et al.· Research in Education, Techn...· 0 citations
Whether AI-enhanced learning environments support or deter learn ers’ sense of cognitive authorship is considered, in the age of AI: in the age of AI, are self-directed learners still authors of their learning.
A human-centred paradigm in which GenAI does not replace but complements teachers is supported, in which GenAI can offer valuable scaffolding or simply produce answers is defined.
Ke-Rong Huang· Journal of Humanities and Cu...· 0 citations
The rapid development of generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) has transformed how teachers and students access, process, and construct knowledge in contemporary education. The increasing capacity of AI systems to provide information, generate ideas, support dialogue, and offer feedback raises fundamental question...