Skip to content

Substituted judgment in health care decision-making: An evolutionary concept analysis.

Sep 2026 · Nursing Ethics · pp. 9697330261487675 · 0 citations · 38 references
Medicine

TL;DR

Substituted judgment is a morally constrained interpretive standard that seeks the decision most faithful to an incapacitated patient's prior values, commitments, and evaluative outlook under acknowledged uncertainty and can help nurses and other clinicians distinguish patient-centered reasoning from adjacent standards and influences.

Abstract

BackgroundSubstituted judgment guides health care decisions for patients who lack decision-making capacity, yet its meaning remains unsettled across legal, clinical, philosophical, and technological literatures. In practice, it is often conflated with best interests, family preference, and clinician judgment, while artificial intelligence preference predictors have renewed debate about what the standard is meant to preserve.AimTo clarify the concept of substituted judgment in health care decision-making using Rodgers' evolutionary method of concept analysis.Research designAn evolutionary concept analysis was conducted to examine the attributes, antecedents, consequences, surrogate and related terms, and disciplinary evolution of substituted judgment.Participants and research contextA multidisciplinary search across five databases with citation searching yielded 162 sources for analysis. Sixty-seven core analytic sources were extracted in full into a structured matrix with an audit trail.Ethical considerationsThe study analyzed published literature and did not involve human participants; institutional ethics approval was not required.FindingsThe concept evolved through four eras: legal origins in equity (1816 to 1969), migration into medicine and the courts (1969 to 1990), codification in bioethics and professional ethics (1990 to 2005), and critique and reinterpretation (2006 to present). Eight defining attributes were identified, including decisional incapacity, the moral relevance of prior personhood, distinction from best interests, surrogate interpretive responsibility, and practical and epistemic uncertainty. Consequences included value-concordant care and preserved patient authority, as well as false certainty, surrogate burden, and overreliance on prediction.ConclusionsSubstituted judgment is a morally constrained interpretive standard that seeks the decision most faithful to an incapacitated patient's prior values, commitments, and evaluative outlook under acknowledged uncertainty. Conceptual clarity can help nurses and other clinicians distinguish patient-centered reasoning from adjacent standards and influences.

View source

Similar papers

Review Aug 2026

Surrogate Medical Decision-Making in Dementia: A Theory-Informed Integrative Review.

Surrogate medical decision-making in dementia reflects an iterative process of appraisal, coping and reappraisal, shaped by contextual, relational and organizational factors that influence emotional outcomes.

Claire McGowan, R. Zoucha, M. Kalarchian · 0 citations
Review Open access Aug 2026

Ethics consultants’ perspectives on the use of artificial intelligence in ethical decision-making for patients incapacitated with no evident advance directives or surrogates: a qualitative study

Findings highlight the need for equity-centered design, transparent communication of data limitations, interdisciplinary development, and ethics consultant involvement in validation before clinical implementation of artificial intelligence in INEADS care.

Aviv Y. Landau, Marsha Williamson, Jiyoun Song et al. · 0 citations
Review Open access Sep 2026

Shared decision-making in patients with stroke: a scoping review

Overall, SDM showed potential benefits in improving patient involvement and decision quality, although evidence remained heterogeneous and limited, and shows a promising but underdeveloped application in stroke care.

Shu-Ting Wang, Ling Liu, Li-Li Yao et al. · 0 citations
Sep 2026

Expertise, Clinical Judgment, and Expert Panels in Nursing Diagnosis Validation: A Methodological Discussion.

PurposeThis methodological discussion examines how expertise, clinical judgment, and expert panel composition should be understood in studies that seek content validity evidence for nursing diagnoses.ApproachThe discussion integrates literature on expertise, clinical decision making, nursing diagnostic reasoning, conte...

M. V. de Oliveira Lopes, V. M. da Silva · 0 citations
Open access Sep 2026

What Is Shared in Shared Decision-Making? Sustaining Care Without Consensus

Hospice admission is often framed as a model of shared decision-making (SDM) at the end of life, yet disagreement can persist even after decisions are made. In South Korea, hospice care is governed by statutes prioritizing patient self-determination while remaining deeply embedded in expectations of family involvem...

Seok Joo Youn · 0 citations
Open access Aug 2026

A hybrid multi-criteria decision-making framework for prioritising clinical determinants of medical futility in the intensive care unit

Determinations of medical futility in the intensive care unit (ICU) are high-stakes, ethically charged, and clinically variable. Contemporary literature increasingly frames such situations as potentially inappropriate treatment (PIT), particularly when physiologically feasible interventions are judged unlikely to provi...

Selman Karadayı, Efehan Ulas, O. Kucuk · 0 citations

We use cookies to run the site and, with your consent, for analytics and to show ads. See our Cookie Policy.